Oddbean new post about | logout

Notes by 1440000bytes | export

 > If the vast majority of users end up needing custodians to interact with the protocol, then controlling the direction of protocol development is irrelevant. Just control the custodians. 

https://xcancel.com/NotASithLord/status/1857208794851483991 
 You should get involved in bitcoin protocol development and bitcoin core to understand some of the things shared in the post.

Everything looks good from outside. It's the same for every open source project. 
 nostr:nprofile1qqs9336p4f3sctdrtft2wlqaq5upjz9azpgylhfd3dplwf005mfrr9spzamhxue69uhkummnw3ezuendwsh8w6t69e3xj7spz3mhxue69uhkummnw3ezummcw3ezuer9wcq3qamnwvaz7tmwdaehgu3wwa5kueg6g89xw and nostr:nprofile1qqsw3znfr6vdnxrujezjrhlkqqjlvpcqx79ys7gcph9mkjjsy7zsgygpr9mhxue69uhhqatjv9mxjerp9ehx7um5wghxcctwvsq3samnwvaz7tmjv4kxz7fwdehhxarjd93kztnrdaksz9thwden5te0wfjkccte9ekk7um5wgh8qatz7tvu4p wrote lot of stuff about supporting decentralized coinjoin implementations in April this year after the arrest of Samourai founders.

I am sure HRF and Opensats can support contributors, maintainers etc. in this repository. 

I work on a different coinjoin implementation which is simpler and works fine with descriptor wallets. However, I want to see joinmarket do better. 
 At what price will Bitcoin change the world? 
 It's not used in Asia for anything except investment. 
 This is the architecture of Qubes OS. It can be used to create secure vaults WITHOUT covenants. One VM to use covenants and get pre-signed transactions based on output restrictions. Another VM which generates a private key, creates pre-signed transactions and securely destroy the key.

https://image.nostr.build/973696c8b3954faeeba57e3e461c372df777c2a29806b1e145d499b9f88770bc.png 
 Everyone knows about Ross. Not many people know Alexandre aka Alpha02: https://xcancel.com/sp3ked/status/1808710404580753520 
 How stablecoins are extending 'USD dominance': https://digitalchamber.org/stablecoinreport/ 
 The problem with wabisabi coinjoin transactions is that you end up with dust UTXOs and need to consolidate them after coinjoin: https://mempool.space/tx/b893d2f3dccf0b4ce22e572e431b97b7a14fdf00992fbfb344937ba717eec793 
 Has anyone tried mining a block with non-standard transactions using DATUM with ocean? 
 Shared by nostr:nprofile1qqs00000009s3zn9xuxx0hglgyt2yds55un0h7gh5ffyvx6z4jz4xpcpz3mhxue69uhhyetvv9ukzcnvv5hx7un89uq36amnwvaz7tmwdaehgu3wvf5hgcm0d9hx2u3wwdhkx6tpdshsxxphhe on twitter
 https://image.nostr.build/281496946c5db4ceec383d8f9b3ef4fa153d3adc3a4410b8f905a3f053ed68d3.jpg 
 These sats could surely be used for something better. Who cares about bitcoin holdings of politicians? 
 What difference does it make in your life if a politician has invested some amount in gold, property, stocks, bitcoin etc.? 
 Neither I have time nor interested in politicians and their investments. 
 Privacy is not achieved simply by using Tor, but by deciding what you want to let the world know.

I achieve privacy every day without Tor. 
 I had lot of enthusiasm in 2017 when price went up.

I don't feel it anymore and think bitcoin is dead if it remains a speculated asset being traded by trusted third parties.

I don't know. I feel very emotional about it because I can't see something being captured by governments I used for payments on darknet. 
 Trump pump. 
 Yeah this is the first time bitcoin price has gone up. Gold was at all time high even before elections but who cares. 
 Sorry but it's a waste of time.  
 1. It is harder to review, test and get consensus on all the opcodes that are part of this proposal.

2. They can be used to build undesirable things. 
 I don't think bitcoin was created for on-chain AMMs. 
 I think we disrespected and ignored satoshi when all the funding, efforts etc. went to fedimint, cashu etc.

Not just satoshi but all the people who discussed ecash without trusted third parties before bitcoin on mailing lists. We are just slaves for investors at this moment and there are very few transactions settling payments on bitcoin.

It's a speculative asset that everyone enjoys when price goes up and not the same as when I started researching bitcoin in 2015.

I can assure you all the conferences in US do not affect normal people in this part of world. Asia still prefers other things for payments and I don't know who are you scaling for. 
 I will be surprised if more than 1% of Asian population is using or interested to use bitcoin for payments.

Sometimes I am confused who are we scaling for. 
 This recent bcap paper looks more like an attack on bitcoin. Not many people will say bad things about it though because 2 authors are investors. 
 Lot of controversial things in the paper that are just opinions. This makes the soft fork politics uglier and delays next soft fork. 
 There isn't much difference in religious and political extremists. Doesn't matter which party or religion or country.

 
 Custodial solutions have better UX compared to self custodial wallets. Getting rugged is a great user experience. 
 Happy to see joinstr in the coinjoin section.

nostr:nevent1qqst0hqwknprspm44ekehzvhvlm733rqk4pnyr0f9n35w7yxm0u6p7cpzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezumt0d5hsyg9c7zuzzsrh9zyqw4zryj3fw3c4wn6r6al49ysp2kpl8gkjnl7tkcpsgqqqqqqs8rsf4e 
 I still use openvpn. Mullvad isn't the only VPN provider. 
 I think VPN providers should support both protocols and let the users decide.  
 People who pretend that something like nostr or better has never been tried are either too young or dishonest.

I was interested in nostr since 2022 because:

- Simple protocol (at that moment)
- Enough libraries to try and implement 
- Some known bitcoiners involved in it 
 PSA: Those of you who uploaded your profile pics via void.cat, no one can see them after the rugg... 
 Will be fun if some of these image upload websites changed the profile pics for some links. 
 Multiple things have happened in a few weeks irl that made me realize I dont have enough money.

I don't want to become millionaire and flex. If you think my projects could help bitcoin, please donate: https://geyser.fund/project/joinstr 
 Thank you everyone.

https://i.imgur.com/CDHPJ5J.png

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzqe5py69vu36g6sdyelxpueqqd7untw7rt9uzk0vkz8my65wxw5keqy88wumn8ghj7mn0wvhxcmmv9uq36amnwvaz7tmwdaehgu3wvf5hgcm0d9hx2u3wwdhkx6tpdshsqgqqqqyeutqr4uqkwjplp4f6t0qqjlvjxe33e77tuc6n9y0365zw7yc9pr0w 
 It's working now. 
 nostr:nevent1qqsqkglzk0ju2wywazr6vzqvanalv38jx2hzytf5xhqd557kmk8024qpzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezumt0d5hsygrxsyng4nj8fr2p5n8uc8nyqphmjddmcdvhs2eajcglvn23ce6jmypsgqqqqqqsu452j5 
 Thanks. It all started by experimenting with python-nostr. 
 This is lame as fuck. 

She’s beautiful. 

Why is everyone so obsessed about other people’s g... 
 They are mostly rigged as well. 
 Cypherpunks write protocols to censor users based on KYC: https://github.com/cashubtc/nuts/pull/106 
 Being optional is irrelevant as such mints would still be considered cashu mints.

Mint knows each authenticated user with a `linkingkey`and account model: https://github.com/cashubtc/nuts/blob/9cb6272e9d1eb26fdfb117318bba825c068e888d/16.md
 https://image.nostr.build/0bc478c5e6563054fe6f46abc5bc88cf46417ce4af9faad6dfb7e72e6a57ea16.jpg

 
 I don't know how things work. Please educate me and explain why this is possible in the first place. 
 Every time a dev says you need less relays I try using less relays & guess what happens I see les... 
 Primal has an interesting feature that you can look at the most cringe posts on the right. 
 Do you think my 15 year old laptop will explode if I try to stream on nostr. 
 Yes 
 what happens if you run Tor through Tor, does this work
(badly, i imagine) 
 It becomes decentralized? 
 In some cases it's better to avoid payments in coinjoin transactions. Payjoin or Octojoin works better in such situations because less or no coordination and transactions look normal.

Also wabisabi isn't the only implementation that allows payments in coinjoin. You can achieve the same with joinmarket and joinstr.

nostr:nevent1qqsdh4exeq2lq2mddgytrp2vafy2h85d3jnjeyq39rqc0v7fgexalhqpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzvuhsygpz42q4zrhx8l3tzm9wzmsfy8mcaxaf3qhzs688ucadd5y2ax6e2spsgqqqqqqs9mqtdu 
 Apparently 22 channels forced closed when my node was offline… wow. Why do ln nodes do this?

M... 
 Was this during the recent runes mint and high fees? 
 If every car is tracking its owner, a bus is like a coinjoin. 

Maybe that's how we should explai... 
 I like the bus analogy. There is another way to describe joinstr.

- An ostrich creates a nest (pool)
- Some female ostriches lay their eggs in the nest (register inputs) 
- Incubation period lasts for a few minutes (coordination using relays)
- Hatching of eggs (new UTXOs)

Eggs were of different colors but the ostriches that come out of these eggs look the same.

https://image.nostr.build/32448fd03646b76fb385e212edd92faca6a5f84f777ceef65f17c4960b4750a2.jpg 
 Ecash exists since 90s with same trade-offs. 
 How will Ten31 invest in custodial solutions then? 
 https://image.nostr.build/f33ce8fe33567faf00fdbd7b0c8624704bd2f39847e6a4eb4a830eb67e80ad32.jpg

nostr:nevent1qqsrm3xc22fcfn4wclzudz0m55spr7m0xpqkmv4mau346ave6jz3cqgpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzvuhsygz89azq7200n9hf9gvxhrfjplccpjz4jqug9eva2r0phz74v6fsrcpsgqqqqqqslednez