Oddbean new post about | logout

Notes by dk | export

 the concept of “intrinsic value” is a scam

it’s all just social consensus 
 Every time a rug is pulled somewhere — be it money or speech —  it’s marketing for sovereignty and freedom 
 let’s help educate more. it can take a lot of study -- it’s a big change to understand. 
 free speech and neutral money are technically very different, but they’re both foundational to how we organize society 
 Daily reminder: if you’re iterating quickly on building the best nostr-native long-form composer I will give you tons of feedback 
 It is a violation of basic human rights to suppress someone's ability to express their thoughts a... 
 thanks for writing this. I had not considered how expressing hate speech can lead to a reduction in continued hate speech. 
 If you are a creator, don’t wait until the tools get easy and the masses get here before you st... 
 🙌

From my upcoming post:

"They may be more open to trying a new approach — publishing in a place that is uncrowded and niche even if it doesn’t provide amazing growth and monetization opportunities yet. It’s an investment in the future. Being early before the masses arrive will prove to be a gift to your future self.” 
 Hbd! 
 Seems like a good moment to share this since GitHub is down. There are open source alternatives t... 
 anyone making progress on a nostr based github alternative yet? 
 whoa! is this getting integrated into a lot of dev workflows? 
 legit! 
 Today, you are the algorithm. ReNote the ideas you want to spread. 
 Nostr needs more UX/design help

Karnage has done a lot to help nostr UX/design, so you should listen to what he expresses as the challenges 👇 nostr:note1h9tupec5eunxcxz4a5ea2hjnympahjtxfxr534wemmjlcqz0g9as8k5ma2 
 Hey everybody. I am new to nostr, just switching over from insta to contribute to - other stuff -... 
 welcome, Anni’s Food! 
 I’m open to considering any conspiracy theories, but…

the more a theory requires more people, orchestrated in secret, required to pull it off, the more skeptical I become

for example, I did a thought experiment with a friend… “how do you know that computer science actually works as believed?” 
 hm... good possible counterpoint.

tho maybe different these days with the Internet and speed/availability of communication from/to everyone? 
 I did as a kid. don’t go any more 
 A lot of our solutions would be amazingly effective at scale (bitcoin value for value), but are m... 
 what do you think Nostr needs most rn to grow?

esp interested in areas that might not have enough attention yet 
 Are you mostly focused on self-serve B2B SaaS apps? Have you discussed/validated any feedback from your target customers yet? 
 Are you thinking about this to improve the video experience on existing clients like Damus or to open up new experiences that can’t be done without it (e.g., something TikTok-like)? 
 What’s the simplest way to use a CLI on Mac/Linux to generate an nsec/npub and sign/verify a message?

NDK? @PABLOF7z @JeffG 
 ty! 🙏 
 At the end of the day, all we have is Proof of Work. 
 the importance of being weird, supporting weird, encouraging weird 
 I’m looking forward to long-form writing being a thing on Nostr 
 Yup, I’m actually writing something on it right now!

but, it’s still pretty challenging to use. I’m involved enough in nostr that I’m quite patient, but it’s not ready for an average substack writer yet. 
 oh yeah, I’m really passionate about better writing tools here and trying to contribute feedback from my writing experiences using various tools. 
 Yes, played with it a bit. Prob one of the top 3, but I don’t believe it’s easy/accessible enough for a typical Substack writer 
 I’m rooting for everyone contributing to this

would there be any value from more cross-collab among these projects or do you think they each take a different enough perspective? e.g. are there opportunities for isolated components that could be contributed/improved/reused across projects? 
 true 
 longer coming soon 
 oh, I didn’t mean to suggest collab with Substack

was thinking about other long-form nostr approaches like Highlighter, Yakihonne, etc. 
 I know of an OG bitcoiner who is vegan

ignore conformity 
 I played with it a long time ago — not my thing

but a good example, imo, of ignoring conformity among bitcoiners 
 good advice

but also: focus your time on stuff you care about and tune out the noise 
 I won’t say anything else about it, sorry 
 def 🤝 
 I’m a beef eater myself, but we still lack a lot of knowledge about how food impacts various bodies. I don’t believe I have the right answer. 
 RE: UK/EU CENSORSHIP, SURVEILLANCE, AND ARRESTS

ELON WILL ACT TOUGH IN PUBLIC AND BEND THE KNEE ... 
 until he picks a new architecture he’s stuck with all the baggage of the past 
 fix the money and the media and you’ll fix politics 
 Damus iOS technically censors you from creating an empty post. true freedom on nostr means the ab... 
 nobody can tell me that i can’t say nothing 
 Bitcoin node status:

Unbothered. Moisturized. Happy. In My Lane. Focused. Flourishing. 
 What other ideas do you have for an “ethical social media” 

I’ll start.  

1. I’d want a... 
 i could also see a create:consume ratio if it’s a client i use as a composer 
 Good morning and pura vida, Nostr! It's time to create notes and send zaps! 💜🤙🏻🫂

Bui... 
 it is a good one ☝️ 
 At the point that you fully understand #Bitcoin, it becomes your risk/reward benchmark for all ot... 
 i used to have a very active private investing life. tho nothing looks as good by comparison anymore 
 JOMO 🧘‍♂️ 
 an algorithm is just a process which makes a computer do a bunch of work toward achieving a goal

Just make sure when you use algorithms they are IN SERVICE OF YOUR GOALS AND NOT SOME CORPORATION’S GOALS

"let’s make computers do things for us” should not be a controversial statement 
 🙏 
 “give me a feed of boring stuff i’ll hate” 😝 
 sure, but algos don’t have to be addictive. e.g. i’d like to try an algo that’s like “catch me up on any notes written about topics X, Y, Z that have received at least 1 zap from someone I follow or have zapped in the past” 
 ah, good point

Just wondering out loud… if something like a verifiable zap could be done, would it be a good idea? I can see pros/cons. But seems like a lot of pros around WoT as you mentioned as well as identity-establishment/information quality.

I understand zaps are private, but just spitballing… seems like if sender/receiver/clients wanted to make it reported/verifiable somehow that might be possible? solutions might touch DLCs, inscriptions or an entirely new technology 
 Has anyone written an article using the composer from Ghost.org? Is it as good as Substack’s composer?

I want nostr tools to be the best in the world and I’ll give tons of user feedback to people building a great article composer. 
 some day we will look back and think it insane that we ever accepted algorithms choosing our media that are not open source 
 noalgo beats corporate-algo any day… but open source, user-switchable algos beats that 
 have you ever tasted an open source one? 
 Early days, but this looks promising:

https://noogle.lol/discover 
 This is pretty new, but looks promising:

https://noogle.lol/discover 
 If I mute an account does it cause their replies to my note not to show up when people open a thread they discovered based on my note?

seems a little complicated… just curious if anyone has done something like this or if it’s just a thing to placate App Store policy 
 that sounds right to me. Do you know-if/think that’s common implementation among clients? 
 censorship-resistance doesn’t mean all of your notes should get seen by everyone at all times. you should be able to publish/share whatever you want and it should be visible to anyone who wants to see it (at the time they’d like to see it)

the tough part is clients need to try to infer when someone might want to see it

if someone follows me, presumably they want to see notes from me (they’re opting their attention into that). If I mute someone/something in a reply to my note that a consumer might otherwise see then a client is taking signal from me (via my mute action) that consumers who arrive at that note via my thread likely don’t want to see that note.

you should still be able to navigate to that muted note if you know that replier’s profile and want to browse notes they wrote. that’s how censorship-resistance works 
 I know I’ve been a vocal advocate for algorithms…

and algorithms complicate these things a lot, but the same principles should apply 
 the nice part is you can obviously use whatever client you’d like…

what if someone enters a thread cuz they follow you, but there are 1000 notes of discourse flowing through that thread? should they all be shown in-order? what if I’m following some of the repliers and viewing the discourse… might their replies be prioritized in my view? Should any other signals like zaps be used to prioritize which ones a consumer sees?

I just think our simple answers work well while nostr is subscale. But these questions of structural philosophy become more important over time. 
 Yeah, I played with the DVMs on Amethyst and I think it’s a nice sneak peek at the future.

I just learned about this website recently which explores the ideas a bit:

https://noogle.lol/discover 
 it’s a good day to commit a thoughtcrime ✌️ 
 you may hate me for saying it, but...

stablecoins accelerate the transition to a bitcoin standard 
 yup, feels familiar, but gets people thinking/trying new stuff 
 I would guess a lot of people would be more comfortable holding what they perceive to be USD instead of BTC (even though over a long enough timeframe that logic is flawed).

depends quite a bit on timeframe, tho

is bitcoin already largely understood by most citizens in Zambia? 
 Are there ways other bitcoiners could contribute to this kind of education?

I hear a lot of people talk about “global south” use-cases, but I suspect most people who say that phrase have no on-the-ground touchpoints/contacts. 
 If you’re building a long-form note composer you should obsess about the quality bar that Substack has achieved

You may not love the centralizing forces present in Substack, but you can’t deny the composer is absolutely world class

Who’s going to be first to meet/beat that bar as a Nostr-native tool? 
 I hadn’t thought about “compiling in markdown”… do you use WYSIWYG tools and then save/copy/paste into a compiling step? Which tools do you use? 
 also, I can both appreciate all the work these teams are putting into these tools, but also recognize that “normie-writers” are not going to go nostr-native until the tools reach a minimum bar which I don’t think anyone has achieved yet 
 ha… most writers don’t have VS Code installed… even very technical writers 
 Ha, I’m so basic I use Apple Notes locally, but I should prob try iA Writer… thanks for the idea! 
 oh, hadn’t seen this before, thanks for sharing. Obsidian looks very polished. So this nostr-writer is just nostr-focused adaptation stuff for Obsidian? 
 I’m more a “vi” guy myself 😉 
 my next long-form post is titled “Does Nostr need a marketing team?”

I made a meme for it https://image.nostr.build/107838000a49437e7b387511afb863469875322a092d11130133993e4030fe06.jpg  
 He’s right tho 
 How do you think about managing the tradeoffs of posting private messages to relays designed for broadcasting messages. Does the NIP already have a philosophy on this or does your product take a point of view?