Oddbean new post about login | logout What's different about the hashtags? https://image.nostr.build/03cce654cd7e309b5ae2ac9dbe57cad70db1a552c89f61960718d25c26f8f8e1.jpg
That is really weird. I have only put the first 3 hashtags into the post, I have no idea why you see all of the other ones. Which client are you using?
Amethyst, most your posts have something going on.. https://image.nostr.build/730942429c0ab2a39e4821b763ede77e12e12f0dcd9418b49f9dcdb4fcd7eb33.jpg
That is strange... Is it just my account? Maybe its some kind of a new feature on Amethyst? @Vitor Pamplona Is this behavior expected?
We always show all hashtags. Looks like you are adding a bunch of them without linking in the content of the post. So Amethyst adds it for the user.
From my knowledge any other client shows only the hashtags included in the text, but Amethyst displays all metadata from the post. Here is the explanation from @Vitor Pamplona nostr:nevent1qqsxhjw9suelvr5vtnudagujxpkkce0jkx764qup7jal0yhfe0rxqycslqkxz
How can amethyst add them for the user if the user did it self? That is weird.
To be technically clear, I somehow added those hashtags unintentionally to the post metadata. But Amethyst is (to my knowledge) the only client that chooses to display those tags from the metadata by default.
Ah ok, thanks for clarification. Still wondering how one can unintentionally ad those tags to the post metadata. Maybe Vitor has an idea.
Hiding hashtag is a spammer tool. They just add all the hashtags to the event, but not at the content. Which makes the post appear everywhere, in every hash tag search, without poluting the message. To counter act, we add all unlisted hashtags back in the post to make it really annoying for followers of that account.
I have been posting through @Shipyard. I literally either copied text from chatGPT (by selecting specific text from a their web app and control C+V) or links straight from media hosting sites. @PABLOF7z any idea why that might happen? It seems additional tags were added to Events JSON which was never my intention.
Can you give me an example event id? Shipyard only adds the tags you explicitly add to the content.
Pretty much all of my posts since at least a couple of days. But here is one in particular @note1mguazjy8ysfapal4aut3hue4mnu4he7pdmccrhrj0p4vaty6pccsxwelma . Basically I had made a promtp to chatGPT which included a large list of popular hashtags and asked him to create a post while only adding a couple of relevant ones. After that I manually selected the post text (including only a couple of hashtags) and copypasted it , but the event was published including a way larger number of tags inside the JSON. In addition to that it seems that those tags also got added to the meme posts I made, where I simply copypasted links to media hosting without adding anything else whatsoever in the note. Example of this @note1vp9re5gyckjae2upvw382urar8wh9demwljhjxefqnv8dx30zzgqch686n
Wait and you say this was posted via shipyard? Did you write it there?? This is full of spam
Yes, I use Shipyard exclusively to make main posts on this account. I did not type the text there, I copypasted it from chatGPT straight to Shipyard. On the screenshot you can see how I intended the posts to look like. I don't even think there is a way to manually add tags to posts through Shipyard, but for some reason it happens (probably through copied text from chatGPT). https://image.nostr.build/ba3d3abb8c08445b6649f5ac1c6a49c3c749b04e38d6c4fe4c031196b7a58283.png
And this is how meme posts are supposed to look - just the image, nothing else. But it seems that those extra tags are being added at some point to them as well. https://image.nostr.build/5caaa9a72ccf5dec770b6b4d7e61466082253ee9d06b6e296aa1b14644a59484.png
To be technically clear, I somehow added those hashtags unintentionally to the post metadata. But Amethyst is (to my knowledge) the only client that chooses to display those tags from the metadata by default.
Ah ok, thanks for clarification. Still wondering how one can unintentionally ad those tags to the post metadata. Maybe Vitor has an idea.
Hiding hashtag is a spammer tool. They just add all the hashtags to the event, but not at the content. Which makes the post appear everywhere, in every hash tag search, without poluting the message. To counter act, we add all unlisted hashtags back in the post to make it really annoying for followers of that account.
I have been posting through @Shipyard. I literally either copied text from chatGPT (by selecting specific text from a their web app and control C+V) or links straight from media hosting sites. @PABLOF7z any idea why that might happen? It seems additional tags were added to Events JSON which was never my intention.
Can you give me an example event id? Shipyard only adds the tags you explicitly add to the content.
Pretty much all of my posts since at least a couple of days. But here is one in particular @note1mguazjy8ysfapal4aut3hue4mnu4he7pdmccrhrj0p4vaty6pccsxwelma . Basically I had made a promtp to chatGPT which included a large list of popular hashtags and asked him to create a post while only adding a couple of relevant ones. After that I manually selected the post text (including only a couple of hashtags) and copypasted it , but the event was published including a way larger number of tags inside the JSON. In addition to that it seems that those tags also got added to the meme posts I made, where I simply copypasted links to media hosting without adding anything else whatsoever in the note. Example of this @note1vp9re5gyckjae2upvw382urar8wh9demwljhjxefqnv8dx30zzgqch686n
Wait and you say this was posted via shipyard? Did you write it there?? This is full of spam
Yes, I use Shipyard exclusively to make main posts on this account. I did not type the text there, I copypasted it from chatGPT straight to Shipyard. On the screenshot you can see how I intended the posts to look like. I don't even think there is a way to manually add tags to posts through Shipyard, but for some reason it happens (probably through copied text from chatGPT). https://image.nostr.build/ba3d3abb8c08445b6649f5ac1c6a49c3c749b04e38d6c4fe4c031196b7a58283.png
And this is how meme posts are supposed to look - just the image, nothing else. But it seems that those extra tags are being added at some point to them as well. https://image.nostr.build/5caaa9a72ccf5dec770b6b4d7e61466082253ee9d06b6e296aa1b14644a59484.png
I have been posting through @Shipyard. I literally either copied text from chatGPT (by selecting specific text from a their web app and control C+V) or links straight from media hosting sites. @PABLOF7z any idea why that might happen? It seems additional tags were added to Events JSON which was never my intention.
Can you give me an example event id? Shipyard only adds the tags you explicitly add to the content.
Pretty much all of my posts since at least a couple of days. But here is one in particular @note1mguazjy8ysfapal4aut3hue4mnu4he7pdmccrhrj0p4vaty6pccsxwelma . Basically I had made a promtp to chatGPT which included a large list of popular hashtags and asked him to create a post while only adding a couple of relevant ones. After that I manually selected the post text (including only a couple of hashtags) and copypasted it , but the event was published including a way larger number of tags inside the JSON. In addition to that it seems that those tags also got added to the meme posts I made, where I simply copypasted links to media hosting without adding anything else whatsoever in the note. Example of this @note1vp9re5gyckjae2upvw382urar8wh9demwljhjxefqnv8dx30zzgqch686n
Wait and you say this was posted via shipyard? Did you write it there?? This is full of spam
Yes, I use Shipyard exclusively to make main posts on this account. I did not type the text there, I copypasted it from chatGPT straight to Shipyard. On the screenshot you can see how I intended the posts to look like. I don't even think there is a way to manually add tags to posts through Shipyard, but for some reason it happens (probably through copied text from chatGPT). https://image.nostr.build/ba3d3abb8c08445b6649f5ac1c6a49c3c749b04e38d6c4fe4c031196b7a58283.png
And this is how meme posts are supposed to look - just the image, nothing else. But it seems that those extra tags are being added at some point to them as well. https://image.nostr.build/5caaa9a72ccf5dec770b6b4d7e61466082253ee9d06b6e296aa1b14644a59484.png
If the tags are there in metadata, I would argue that showing them is a good and proper approach for Amethyst. Otherwise, I might think there is a bug in the tag specific stream I am subscribed to when I see your posts present without the tag.
I meant its Amethysts choice at the end of the day. If they are fine with their users experiencing NOSTR differently from practically any other client, so be it. In my particular case what is interesting is that those additional tags are unintended and are somehow included at some point of post creation through Shipyard.
