Oddbean new post about | logout

Notes by Gerald Glickman | export

 "Privacy is one kind of freedom of expression: the freedom to disclose oneself to the world. Enabling that freedom enables all the benefits of free expression too. Privacy, then, has significant instrumental value."

Excellent work here by the Resistance Money crew nostr:nprofile1qqszv3w274cx5vtk0jfp2v5htgrelpv4pcgqd02svh6a6qsnu6zg49spzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezuamfdejsz9thwden5te0v4jx2m3wdehhxarj9ekxzmnyqyv8wumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnwdaehgu3wvdhk6tnpw57gdmf4, nostr:nprofile1qqs8753ha8mh5gky4ztzf3avx89w097c43q5fvpyjwys6487uuuehngpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduhssdjs5k, and nostr:nprofile1qqsfxkeuza76hnkuj2028vgqt52f9u9fl0d2z25xee3c80hyqfe74lgpz4mhxue69uhk2er9dchxummnw3ezumrpdejqz9rhwden5te0wfjkccte9ejxzmt4wvhxjmcprpmhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuumwdae8gtnnda3kjctvrjcls7

https://www.btcpolicy.org/articles/privacy-in-public-part-1-what-privacy-is-and-why-it-matters

"No privacy, no freedom" h/t nostr:nprofile1qqsqfjg4mth7uwp307nng3z2em3ep2pxnljczzezg8j7dhf58ha7ejgpz4mhxue69uhkummnw3ex2mrfw3jhxtn0wfnszynhwden5te0wahhgtn4w3ux7tn0dejszxthwden5te0wdjkuerfwshxummnvekxzun99e3k7mgrcp7e2 
 Look to my coming on the first light of the fifth epoch, at dawn look to the east.
https://image.nostr.build/a071035a2d9501b951c8eb8ee0313be5ee23393ff16364a11c24f391ed444bf5.jpg 
 The highway's jammed with broken heroes
On a last chance power drive
Everybody's out on the run tonight
But there's no place left to hide

Together, Wendy, we can live with the sadness
I'll love you with all the madness in my soul
Oh, someday, girl, I don't know when
We're gonna get to that place
Where we really wanna go and we'll walk in the sun
But 'til then, tramps like us
Baby, we were born to run 
 Definitely an option.  Digital signatures ftw.

Here's what I posted yesterday on X:

Well done!  I love the intent and execution here!

To take it one step further, has River considered enabling customers to publicly vouch that the results of their validation excercise are legit?  I feel like this is the last mile of this intent to really bring it home.

This could be done by issuing a Verifiable Credential to customers, and then enabling a 1-click "vouch" button that compiles a message which customers can digitally sign and publish using their VC.  The messages could be pushed to any verifiable data registry of your choice, but could start out as simple as just River hosting these signed messages on your website / infrastructure.

This information would now be public and corroborated by your individual customers, adding that real credibility that you all are going for in terms of an open, public certification process. 
 John Henry told his captain
"A man ain't nothing but a man
But before I let your steam drill beat me down
I'd die with a hammer in my hand, Lord, Lord
I'd die with a hammer in my hand"

https://image.nostr.build/2d60121a8514ea31ddaecbb3754c1d5b5a7e61ee31a96018b7f48272851a09d5.jpg 
 Anyone have constant imposter syndrome? 
 Yep.  Also, I've done 9,000 things, so, comes with the territory. 
 And yet so few 
 Bitcoiners FUDing nostr (for silly reasons, not like legit critique or requests for improvement) ... 
 What criticisms, in your mind, are valid?

Key rotation?
Relay dependence? 
 Who is working on key rotation for Nostr? 
 Thank you! 
 I'm a Nostr newb.  I presume the adoption and implementation of this is client-specific, is that right? 
 Nashville goals next week:

- Meet with and learn from everyone there about manifesting businesses that deliver heat from mining

- Find the right role at a company that wants to advance Decentralized Identity in the United States

About mining: geraldglickman.com/mining

Let’s build businesses that use Bitcoin mining heat!

There is so much to talk about here, but my goal is conduct a comprehensive and OPEN survey (data will be shared) of top potential use cases for leveraging the heat from Bitcoin mining.

About Identity:

Let's build a world where individuals control the use of their identity!

My 10 years in fraud and identity risk have shown me that we must collectively and urgently work to enable a new paradigm of digital identity in the US.

Will you be in Nashville next week for the conference?  I'd love to speak with you about either of these topics if they are of interest to you or your business 🤝 
 
biometricupdate.com/202406/uk-trai

Everyone should reject this kind of stuff in principle.

"By interpreting facial expressions and other non-verbal cues, the system can identify passengers who may be distressed or agitated, potentially allowing officers to preempt conflicts or emergencies." 
 This seems to be a good take.  Curious if anyone disagrees or has a counterpoint. 

nostr:note1eh... 
 First 4 paragraphs are spot on.

I disagree with the last one.  The point of anchoring the DID and the DID Document on-chain is that there are no other external dependencies.

https://twitter.com/AsherHopp/status/1785840844895027507?t=VMJpO7W509AlNQ1_6Yu-qw https://image.nostr.build/e26a63e8366d1be3101cb61b76c2feafbe6e66fc889ea8522ad7687a7395e7b8.jpg 
 Saylor is trying to create a trust anchor. But since anyone can create their own DID:BTC without ... 
 No, you're combining the notion of a DID and a Verifiable Credential.  A DID by itself proves / attests nothing.  A DID is not KYC.  Lots of misunderstanding here. 
 The anchor is the DID itself, no?  Attestations relating to KYC should come in the form of a Verifiable Credential that are controlled / issued to that DID (hopefully) as opposed to a simple signed message by a DID relating to some other entity. 
 Yes, agree, ty.  The goal (and current gap in this space, IMHO), is around your last point and deriving an open trust model / framework that would enable others to make similar (if not the same) "verified" attestations about other DIDs.

I personally think this is a novel concept (putting the entire DID Doc on-chain), and I'm confused why people are shitting on it.  Many are quick to espouse anti-kyc blah blah (and they're not wrong), but at the same time identity is broken and we need to find a way forward.  DIDs and VCs are the obvious answer, and will return consent and sovereignty to individuals when it comes to the storage and utilization of their PII. 
 We already have decentralized IDs. They're called npubs. 
 To some extent, yes. 
 I just watched MicroStrategy’s launch video of their new Orange ID platform and honestly I don... 
 You're almost there.  DIDs, when paired with VCs, are what unlock a new paradigm of identity.

https://www.w3.org/TR/vc-data-model-2.0/ 
 Doesn’t nostr prove that you don’t need a blockchain for “decentralized identity?”

🤦... 
 Kinda.  But who runs the relays? 
 Ah so now the filter bois are joining the “we no like Saylor” club

Got it! 
 Lame identity thing? 🤦  Never had your identity stolen, huh Trey? 
 Gotcha.  What's lame about the approach? 
 Le Sigh.

Please understand that your inability to accept reality is the source of all pain.

You do not have to agree or like it, but you must accept what is.  Only after accepting reality are you in a reasonable position to derive and execute a worthwhile plan.  Game on!

https://image.nostr.build/9ac88c0232fd908ae9f2f0df3800e734d50964bfbb59f50298688cd495019592.jpg 
 100% accurate in my experience. ✨ 

nostr:note1gvmdpjjm25zdc6lk2se2rfclnm8u6a9nls4pwkchch8vszdm... 
 Indeed! 
 I just realized I was feeling unsettled the other day, took me a minute to realize the remedy - it had been a full 18 months since I listened to In Rainbows.

1 hour later, felt refreshed and reset. 
 The most important thing with the #Bitcoin ETFs that most people seem to miss is the rate of acc... 
 Why? 
 Nobody get it! nostr:note1xfzsqfe3u6y2ljfsy7y7vwmw7sjjesx56t0ytvf9huve0fcpt6msdyvg94 
 To be fair, it is nuanced and there are a lot of evolving developments.  But I agree that ANY form of censorship of the network should be met with upmost resistance in principle, given the introduction of human subjectivity.
https://image.nostr.build/98e048d11005dad5b9c00b10af9a5db9edf68d2cb2e0a6530956d5926e4d2aab.jpg 
 So good

nostr:nevent1qqs0nw4mgmnje3qvcpdh46qgtjlq00y5zgz4ut29clj20x5jsghfxngpp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqzyruwd3jrgtc7q5jgqccwylsszmwwxh7r5c2wvpp5lm625fgrx2x2jqcyqqqqqqgcjcszv 
 I'm healthy, loved by friends and family and have a nice stack on chain. 

I am blessed. 

I made... 
 Good attitude!  Stay after it! 
 GM fam. 
 Then comes the day
Staring at myself I turn to question me
I wonder: do I want the simple, simple life that I once lived in well?
Oh, things were quiet then
In a way they were the better days
But now I am the proudest monkey you've ever seen
Monkey see, monkey do, yeah 
 There are several people who work at banks who are there because they see it as the highest leverage (and perhaps only?) way to advance Bitcoin enablement and adoption. 👋

Caitlin is an absolute legend. 
 Right back at you 🤝 
 Common argument:

1. Halvings introduce no new information about supply.
2. If so, halvings canno... 
 Fascinating to ponder.

My POV: just because we have information and a high-level of confidence doesn't mean we always rationally take action with that information.  Yes, Bitcoin futures now have a large and liquid market, but it is still very reactive to narratives, and narratives are reinforced and amplified by actions (human and otherwise) not yet taken.

Even when that first action is 100% predictable (halving) , the results of the amplified narratives are unclear even when they might seem logical / clearly causal.

Humanity's understanding of Bitcoin is not priced in, let alone a specific event like a halving.  Bullish.  Also, I have no clue! 
 One behind the next in line
It's inspection time
Let me check your design 
 Define inefficiences? 
 I see.  The issue is a context-specific answer from a generalized statement.

"Optimal" is also completely subjective.  Is it optimal for a company to dump pollution in a river?  For their P&L, yes.  For a broader set of stakeholders / context space, perhaps not. 
 But yet to find the suitable meme template.  I think I need the intersecting circles one... 
 A legal tactic to be aware of is to make unfollowable laws, and then selectively enforce them.

S... 
 Lyn, do you think is a legal case to be made that exchanges MUST use mixers to comply with GBLA?

Trying to think of Overton Window grenades for this overreach. 
 Ty, Lyn!  Appreciate you and your work!

I'd be curious to understand if other viable legal defenses are being discussed and deployed in an organized fashion. 
 Wow, the phoenix wallet migration was flawless 
 Yep, same for me 
 This thing on? 
 One of the hardest things for folks to understand and grasp:

In nuance, you find truth. With tru... 
 No quite, for me.  My frame:

In nuance, you realize there is no truth.  With this truth, you find peace. 
 Where there's a will, there's a way. 
Event not found
 Well said! 
Event not found
 It's pretty different than Ion in that it stores the DID Document directly on-chain, so ofc it's less "efficient".

As for the broader sentiment, agree to disagree 🤝 
 Do you normally expect people to engage with you when you lead with "perhaps you're retarded?" 🤦