Oddbean new post about | logout

Notes by melvincarvalho | export

 True story. 

Primal feeds are now available on Amethyst, Nostrudel, and any other Nostr client t... 
 Speed? 
 #pkdns on Hacker News

Pkdns: DNS server resolving via mainline DHT

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42026143 
 #pubky dns servers, use one, or run your own, and add to the list.  Open protocols FTW!

https://github.com/pubky/pkdns/blob/master/servers.txt 
 Read "Plotting Hitler's Death", by Joachim Fest.  Gives a good account of what it is like to live under a totalitarian regime. 
 I don't care about #Pubky. I'm NostrOnly. 
 You analyzed it correctly.  Makes every npub a censorship-resistant dns so you can own a piece of the internet.

Where nostr is 6 nodes #pubky is 6 million.

The two systems can work together but pubky is working now.  Nostr could integrate it.  It might take a day, it might take a year, but it wont take 10 years.

Users get 10x or 100x more options.  So some are adopting early. 
 Works on ditto.  Not a fan am amethyst, myself.   
 IT WORKS WITH NPUB!!

$ nslookup -type=txt  _npub.8xssyidksmiup9og9k47s41hy7zt71r74fm6zhoc3cuxj9qr7ray 66.78.40.76

_npub.8xssyidksmiup9og9k47s41hy7zt71r74fm6zhoc3cuxj9qr7ray	text = "npub17zh5navmw7zrdmdfgm8khmeef0zrgyn4kjx4g2x6j0fkcyg7m8wqe3zmwj"



nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzqzklvar4enzu53t06vpzu3h465nwkzhk9p9ls4y5crwhs3lnu5pnqy2hwumn8ghj7erfw36x7tnsw43z7un9d3shjqpq3qgtda75lqr0ydtcn38d3z76lxnatc95ym9wykhcufdzjsk9lars3sv7r5 
 wow governments are actually substantial in this case
nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzqmqyf6rnsnjxr69wma... 
 100x bigger than lightning! 
 DONALD TRUMP AND KAMALA HARRIS ARE PART OF THE SAME CLUB. 
 It's a club.  And you aint in it.  -- George Carlin 
 Took me ages to find this.  But worth watching 1 minute of this.  I set the time stamp.

Inventor of the web being asked what he would have done differently.  #pubky fixes this!

https://www.youtube.com/live/N_DvBPnNigM?t=1965s 
 t=1965s 
 Decentralized dns is working with #pubky and nslookup.  HUGE!

Decentralized DNS means no more takedowns, no gatekeepers, and your data is stored across a resilient, battle-tested, massive network of nodes

nslookup -type=txt  _webid.8xssyidksmiup9og9k47s41hy7zt71r74fm6zhoc3cuxj9qr7ray 37.27.13.182

Server:    37.27.13.182
Address:  37.27.13.182#53

Non-authoritative answer:

_webid.8xssyidksmiup9og9k47s41hy7zt71r74fm6zhoc3cuxj9qr7ray  text = "https://foaf4.solid.social/profile/card#me 
 I forgot about this because I didn't focus much on the DNS server aspect of Pkarr.

But yes, beca... 
 Can you tell me exactly what to put in here, to set it up?

https://app.pkarr.org/ 
 Consider the value of what verifiably censorship-resistant DNS would bring to nostr.  It works.

https://pubky.tech/ 
 "Dont vote, dont encourage them" -- Adam Back

What can you do that is more effective than voting?  Easy.  Find a small project on github that you like.  And add a star to it.  Most developers do not get any payment whatsoever for their work.  A simple star can make all the difference between having a good life, or being motivated to help others.  Especically on the smaller projects, I guarantee it will be noticed.  And it will have a much bigger impact than voting harder on your designated election day.

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzps0x2pwq9k5drv99k0tdkmsekt4j9hx4fu8gvvrwez3p8yptx9t7qy2hwumn8ghj7erfw36x7tnsw43z7un9d3shjqpqgycyj4jqt6dn8x72xtsm42mkjfumnqdfw050xx0ylstxc6du60dqvex8z9 
 Other side of the coin is that if you vote for one or the other (both are deep state) they feel they have a mandate.  They also know how the game is rigged, they know the lies they tell, and what they see is turkeys voting for thanksgiving. 
 Hosted DNS

Use one of the hosted DNS servers to try out pkdns quickly.

- Verify the server is working.
- Configure your system dns.
- Browse the self-sovereign web.

https://github.com/pubky/pkdns 
 I can say that lip syncing monsters is hard!

https://melvin.solid.social/public/video/monster.mp4 
 Yes, true 
 What! 
 Which app is this? 
 Gotcha.  Not an amethyst fan.  So nothing surprises me with that client.   
 This would literally NEVER have survived without the fiat standard.

Same with companies like Ama... 
 Why?  Free market on a bitcoin standard would have been even better for them.  As bitcoin is not rigged. 
 Are expiring posts technically feasible on nostr? 
 Yes 
 Done some basic calcs, based on inflows, exchange coins, ratios etc.  Barring a game-changing event, btc will hit 100k before end of next year. 
 I would not pay too much attention to these charts.  Consider the inflow/outflow and coins on the exchange, plus the Greyscale sales.  Extrapolate back to the start of the ETF, and compare with mined coins.  Then look at the delta of coins on exchanges, and extrapolate those flows.  It's a fairly regular pattern barring mass liquidations.  I guess we get 1-2 liquidation dates per year.  ETFs are going to drive it steadily up.  I guess the only MAJOR risk is a chain split via a contentious fork.  I hope that does not happen before 2026. 
 I know what you mean.  I dont often do this either.  But I do happen to have the best track record in the history of bitcoin, and other things outside bitcoin, I won the biggest and most famous prediction competition in europe.  Generally I lean towards your stance.  But if you have a sound methodology, you can buck the trend.  This is simply supply and demand trends.  Nothing magical going on. 
 You are conflating random outcomes with games of skill.  There's no place you can go from that starting point.  FWIW bayesian analysis is what you want to use here.

Adoption is correlated to supply demand dynamics, but folks normally misguess the impact.  For example lightning is everywhere but only actually 5000 btc.  Capital is more important.

Prohibition is likely to happen on alt coins, these things dont happen fast and are given with lots of notice.  There could be prohibition in the next 14 months, but that would be an unexpected game-changing event.  More likely is a liquidation.  Or something like a contentious fork that could split the chain.  Then all bets are off.

However supply/demand with a business-as-usual next year, should see it trend to 100k+.   
 Who do you think will win the election? 
 Deep State 
 Thank you for doing this.  It's a big deal for the internet. 
 Would it be possible to change DNS servers in chrome?  Or use a proxy like privoxy? 
 The privacy properties are a hoax too

nostr:nevent1qqswv5j3kj8c9qtc4a8m8lkxqxmvegpl28s9ppxdephzt... 
 Ecash is better than the status quo.  But it can be over hyped.  In a small set its possible to match ip addresses to users.  I think a mints over tor would help alot here.   
 This is impressive work.  Now, if you put your decentralized censorship resistant domain name in your NIP-05, you might just win the internet!

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzqzklvar4enzu53t06vpzu3h465nwkzhk9p9ls4y5crwhs3lnu5pnqy2hwumn8ghj7erfw36x7tnsw43z7un9d3shjqpq954hglnch6k0xxvl8lfg8l0gq8rgq6uzdr4pth3ymgeue0tjrrjs92e2ss 
 I want to make pubky so good that no indiehacker can be bothered setting up a backend to validate... 
 Webfinger was by far the weakest part in the stack.  So many mistakes like spinning up a new URI scheme, inventing a new JSON format, and moving away from its original use case.   
 FWIW the inventor of unhosted/remotestorage, now works on Solid.  I remember going to the first unhosted meetups over 10 years ago, and still know one of the team.  But after a decade it's yet to take off in a major way, and newer solutions have come along. 
 -- Aren't you worried that someone will steal the money?
-- No.  I'm worried that someone steal the wheel barrow.

😂 

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzqevk6qqae8hq46de9yraeyq9gcsfsj3zzwy6385we4rxppzwre0dqy2hwumn8ghj7erfw36x7tnsw43z7un9d3shjqpqtt2l7459u7p92jrr2w0gag7mjs5fghp9j4xflapzf3uv8jle4a9s6yzcj6 
 In his book, "Technique", he basically predicts, and describes the "Algorithm", under which we all live.

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzq2y69qzemrfp9p4qvcm2wkaeam2wynxqyxdrra2df5luj5va4exrqy2hwumn8ghj7erfw36x7tnsw43z7un9d3shjqpqs3cce2tqyzjak8rvy0t5w3cs99wfl3cmy6dz9d0m8jkad7prjjvqtusjyq 
 Hey everyone! 👋 I’m curious about the security of using the Orange Pill App to connect with ... 
 Yo nostr:nprofile1qqstnem9g6aqv3tw6vqaneftcj06frns56lj9q470gdww228vysz8hqpzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuur... 
 If nostr integrates #pubky I think keet drops out for free. 
 Yes, indeed.  Pear should be a simple integration after #pubky.  It almost drops out for free.  Question is who will be first to innovate.  Relays I think have evolved towards the email type model.  I strongly believe that relays are still better than the status quo, but we are heavily reliant on damus, and the relay network is centralized.  If you remember a few lawyers once went after bittorrent and sent lots of shutdown and litigation letters.  Nostr would not survive such a wave.  But bittorrent did survive it, and so its censorship resistance is proven and powers pubky.  Once we have that then we could have pear, pretty much for free, but I think there's alot of pear skeptics.  To give you an idea I integrated pubky into my software in about 2 hours this weekend, it's an easy task.  The technical barrier is small, the psychological barrier is large. 
 iroh is shit coiners? 
 You made me realize something incredible.  Nostr's value proposition is that many clients can be built using the same rules.  Leading to a diversity of clients doing different things.  And so many different developers are funded to give different features.  But actually not one client is innovating here, they are all innovating in a centralized way according to a centralized group-think.  Something has gone wrong.  But this is also an opportunity.  Tweak the funding model to get back to innovation. 
 Ugh.  Uninstall. 
 Agree, better than the status quo.  However the devil is in the detail and there are nuances.  If you want to maximize impact and do the most good for the most people, choosing where to invest your time and energy is critical.  And it is a moving target.  That is why scrutiny is so important.  Having observed 1000+ projects over more than a decade 90% do not make it.  You cant always predict which ones will, but you can see the ones that give themselves a good chance, and you normally have to get most things right.  Worst thing for a dev is to invest time in a project that doesnt make it.  But, especially with AI coming, we are on the brink of something big. 
 Yup seen this movie before for 2 decades with libretroshare 
 Yes, about right.  Nostr was in fact one of those destined for the scrap heap.  Even its creator had moved on to other things.  You have no idea the work and team effort it took to get it to where it was noticed by jack.  After that it was relatively easy.  But still to level up nostr is at this point going to take enormous work, and luck.   
 "I'm just going to keep stealing their memes" 😂  
 Whoever wins between #nostr and #pubky, I can’t lose since I’ve got both. The nsecs are the same in each systems.  It’s like having both an Android and an iPhone; either way, I get the best of both worlds. But then it hit me – we just recreated walled gardens all over again. Why can’t these systems work together seamlessly? How did we end up back here, building fences instead of bridges? 
 Hyperlinks are universial.  The U in URL stands for universal really.  But it is also uniform.  Everyone uses it the same way.  Which is why the web won.  Nostr is an http upgrade protocol so it inherits some of that from the parent protocol.  Network effect still play a role.   
 PS your comment reminds me of marshall mcluhan! 
 I have a copy of War and Peace in the Global Village.  Quite a work. 
 Its the only Paul in the city that does it, and it's delicious! 
 For the record, the reason Nostr has Negentropy is because Iroh team popularised the Range-based ... 
 You're defeating your own argument here.  Your thesis that bittorrent mainline is censorship-resistant because it verifiably has millions of nodes and 15 year track record, and something smaller is untested and experimental.

Git also has 15 years track record and millions running the software.  Something new is untested and experimental.

As you keep pointing out we'll never get a chance to bootstrap such networks again.   
 Yes, can be done in phase 2.  Use bitcoin utxo as a tie-breaker, and then market for short names. 
 Surely this is solved already by using a CNAME? 
 Sota there is Runes 
 Bitcoin is definitely more trust worthy than ICANN.  There's no rent seeking with bitcoin, it just operates as a time-chain to operate as a tie-breaker if two people want the same name.  And you can also make a fun trading game.  There's no rent seeking because it's not renewed every year, bitcoin is property rights. 
 Global naming system creates a standard reference point.  It's useful for some things, and less useful for others.  If it were not useful, everyone would let their domain names expire.  But they dont, so people see value in it. 
 I did orginally say it was for free, but nuh corrected me.  Yes there is a  tiny 1kb storage cost which I estimated to be 1/1,000,000 of a satoshi or a "microsat".  For 1 satoshi we could get everyone on nostr a domain :) 
 33 
 It almost became the number of time:

"the adoption of the mathematically simplest, and most Christian, implementation of the 33-year cycle would logically specify the existence of a meridian or narrow band of longitudes within which, and only within which, the Nicene edict could stay correct. This would probably have come to be seen as God's chosen meridian by all Churches that recognised the Nicene council."

https://www.hermetic.ch/cal_stud/gods_longitude.htm 
 Absolutely.  John Dee was the person that invented the term "British Empire".  He was not only the greatest mathematician of his day, he was the greatest linguist and the greatest scienitest and alchemist.  His theories, especially on conic sections, optics and geometry were centuries ahead of his time.  He co-founded Trinity College Cambridge, where Newton was professor.  He had the biggest library in europe, and the influenced the wizard archetype.  It's possible he advised Queen Elizabeth to purchase New Amsterdam from the dutch and make it New York.  With that line being the stable equinox.  8 leap years in 33 is vastly more accurate than what we have today.  Humans will often celebrate annivesaries on the wrong day and not notice. But crabs would notice.  His work the Monas is one of the most powerful books written.  He also unified religoin and science with his work on communicating with the angels, Enochian.  He did change alot, and people like him come around every few centuries.  He was kind of the Satoshi of his day.