Oddbean new post about | logout
 If the purpose of Slack is to discuss business within your company internally... why do you need Nostr relays for that?

If the purpose of Nostr is censorship resistance over relays, why do you want Nostr keys without relays? Wouldn't that increase attack surface for the CIA?

Therefore, I'd recommend using existing tools like Matrix or XMPP on a self-host VPS.  And NOT using some random web app 
 Great points. Asking mostly for community based chats. The key parameters I’m looking for are:
1. Not volunteering plaintext message content to Intel agencies 
2. Good UX
3. Not adding another piece of infra I have to manage


Bonus: don’t leak any metadata 
 How many people in the group chat? like 20 or 200?
If it's 20 people, you can try simpleX.  If it's 200, you want matrix.

Are people outside the organization contacting you for support?  If so, that likely rules out simpleX and nostr

Are you trying to hide the metadata? If not, could use someone else's matrix server, one of the public ones 
 Probably in the 50-100 range no support 

Just trying to get these people off volunteering IM data for AI based Intel machines 
 you'd actually probably be better off with Signal if you're not interested in running the VPS.
Signal can do private groups of 100