Oddbean new post about | logout
 You can get banned from a mastodon instance can you not? I don’t know about blue sky and what’s possible with their moderation. 
 Not if you run your own instance. Which anyone can do for just a few dollars a month.

When Bluesky is fully up and running and allowing people to run their own instances there then it would function more like Nostr than the fediverse from what I understand. 
 When there was an exodus to Mastodon, all the techie people I knew were confused af about which mastodon server to join. I don’t think anyone even thought of running their own. Take a step back to non-techie people and you’ll have few to none running their own instance.
You don’t have this problem on nostr. 

I’m leaving blue sky out because I just don’t know much about it or what it aims to become. 
 Oh for sure, I don’t expect non-techie people to run their own instances for just personal accounts. And sure, you can get banned if you don’t follow the instance rules. But again, if you can use Google then you can find a handful of services that will stand up a server for you within a few minutes if you pay a few dollars. But yeah, that’s still an issue.

Nostr doesn’t have that issue, but has plenty of others, especially for non-techie people. I’ve been in IT for over a decade now and I have worked with plenty of people you’d call techie that don’t have a clue about public/private keypairs. And the relays are confusing for newbies. Understanding what they are exactly, how many should you have, and which ones should you use. Discoverability is also very difficult on Nostr from my experience. It can be difficult to find who to follow if you aren’t a Bitcoin fanatic. So from my experiences, it’s been easier for the normal person to adopt something like the Fediverse or Bluesky than Nostr. The average person also likely isn’t worried about getting banned, so that isn’t as big of a draw to them.

*All opinions above are my own and likely to be incorrect to the majority of Nostr users today* 
 Yeah I agree with a lot of this, except spinning up your own servers by googling around. 
 Like with bitcoin adoption, I see nostr adoption as slow going but assured because there will always be people out there that desperately need an uncensorable speech platform. 

Bitcoin will make it all the way to a global money used by everyone someday because of the network effects of money. They won't have a choice. However Nostr's future isn't as assured. Like you said the average person isn't likely to worry about being banned, and payments over social isn't as appealing to them as we like to think it is.

But Nostr, like Linux, has that awesome usefulness in solving techie problems behind the scenes that will keep it growing regardless, even if the mainstream keeps using their microsoft and apple products forever.  I think we need to be prepared to accept this future for it.  
 >I see nostr adoption as slow going but assured because there will always be people out there that desperately need an uncensorable speech platform.
True, but if Nostr grows more with people on the fringe and more extreme ideas than the majority of the mainstream, then the "normals" are much less likely to adopt it because they can't reach the people they want to.

>Bitcoin will make it all the way to a global money used by everyone someday because of the network effects of money.
😬 I don't share your confidence about Bitcoin on this. It could. But by no means is it inevitable.

I think it would be a great thing for Nostr to grow and expand its audience, but I believe it has a more difficult road ahead of it than the other current options out there like ActivityPub and Bluesky. 
 I've literally never met anyone who is using bluesky, nor have I even heard of activitypub. Is that like a bar where they do arts & crafts? 

These aren't serious competitors, and even if they were, the serious privacy advocates are all working on Nostr, so it's the only one that activists are going to use.

...And the more authoritarian govts become, the more everyone becomes an activist. 
 >These aren't serious competitors, and even if they were, the serious privacy advocates are all working on Nostr, so it's the only one that activists are going to use.

I'm going to argue that at this point, Nostr isn't a serious competitor to the others as far as social networks go. If security is what you're after, then sure, it's currently better in that regard, but until more people know about it and the onboarding process is easier, then that doesn't mean much. It could be the most secure platform ever built but if people find it confusing or difficult to use, or don't know anyone on it, then they aren't going to use it.