Last time I did this, I did it as a thread. 

& it went good, people shared the ones they liked the most. 

Thought I’d give this a try now.. 

 Also is this broken on any clients ?? 

 Damus just shows a carousel of photos at the bottom which kinda sucks because you can’t read the captions together with the pics. 

 Same with primal and Nostur. Would be great to be able to compose a note with an “in line” photo, or add a caption to it 

 hopefully somebody makes a NIP for it 

cc: @fiatjaf @PABLOF7z @hodlbod @jb55 @miljan @Magister Michael Dilger M.Sc. @Kieran @Vitor Pamplona 

nostr:note1u6lh266pnjcw40p7klgx0rz3p2s4awnkuv5fl5f9rucj5symq83shzsfcv 

 Brought it up when running the @NostReport a million times 

 The note has the long list, and then all the images at the end.  So no client is going to show the images under each bit of text unless the note is composed that way.  I don't see any reason a note couldn't be composed that way.  In fact as an example, here is my first image:

https://scitechdaily.com/images/G299-Type-Ia-Supernova.jpg

And here is my second image:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d2/Saturn_-_High_Resolution%2C_2004.jpg

How do they render for you? 

 That’s what I’m trying to say.. there’s no way in any client to currently compose it that way where you can add a description to each individual image and even if 1 client did it it wouldn’t really be interoperable across the ecosystem 


and for me it rendered the same, text of the note and then two images on the carrousel which doesn’t really fix anything the cool thing would be individual text descriptions of each image 

 It’s probably just the client I’m viewing it on, which is why I’m saying if there’s a solution and no NIP then it’s not the same experience for everyone https://i.nostr.build/Yg9Rq.jpg  

 On gossip the images render in place, like in Pablo's image.  For your client they render in a carousel at the bottom.

You are right that there is no NIP about how to render the notes.  But I think moving an image from the middle to the bottom isn't correct and was probably just an easy way to avoid dealing with image-text interlacing issues while the dev worked on more pressing issues. 

 That NIP won’t be worked on anytime soon right.. I’ve never heard any discussions around this 

 what do you think about ALT image descriptions as well https://i.nostr.build/wGvDv.png  

 I ain't got no problems with alt image descriptions. Gossip should probably render them if the image hasn't been loaded yet. I'll contact the developer. 

 gib thanks to dev from me 🫂 

 Coracle does allow you to compose notes and choose where the images show up 

 I’m gonna start using Coracle for these types of notes then 🤝

Thank you sir! 

 This is what longform is for 

 I can do longform within Damus ? 

 Would be easier to read if the caption/description for each image immediately preceded or followed the image as opposed to 2 separate lists and images unnumbered 

 Also a good candidate for a Corny Chat Slideset 

 You can add individual descriptions to each slide ? hadn’t seen that 

 Yes. Lot of people dont use the captions out of laziness but if you have them, like in this case, it really helps with context. 

 That’s probably why I had never seen it lol 

Those lazy fucks 

 Clients never really had this in mind I guess, idk if they’ll do anything about it anytime soon either.. it’s probably not even in their radars. Which I completely understand, but yeah it probably would have to be a NIP so everyone is on the same page n it’s all interoperable. 

 @elsat another feature request that prob won’t happen my fren lol 

 Keep em coming sleepy 🙏 

 It's a long note, which are annoying to have to scroll past, but it's not a long form note, which is a different Kind, I believe. Long form notes are those you would create in habla.news or highlighter.com or Yakihonne. It's better to use those for long notes like this, imo. 

Great note, btw! 

 I like threads a lot and I think we should encourage more clients to properly rendered them; most clients don't do it well but threads were a good thing in twitter as they allow very precise discussion

https://highlighter.com/e/nevent1qqs2c5u8ncftwhderskzjvz4k88pa0ka5qcjp6em8a9xfjal70z4qds60keh2