Oddbean new post about | logout
 I feel like this note explains most of what I need to know about some nostr builder's visions of the future. Not to put everyone in one basket, but my technology world view is essentially completely opposed to this. I don't even want a smart phone anymore.

nostr:note18tp3qvuzelnndlvp5ll4z7lq008vhfut6y53e0skc44p7cldr6dsmpurlp  
 What's your vision of the future of software then? 
 Generally, advocate for less technology integration into culture if that makes sense. I don't believe there is a way to get away from the surveillance state without removing technology integration personally. I am specifically speaking of consumer technology, mobile phones, addictive software, social technology and so on. I'm not saying social media does not have it's importance, but IMO it should not be stable enough to form careers from, if that makes sense. The economic exchange of user engagement should not be sustainable enough. 

As far as software goes, I build and advocate self-hosting, people should physically own their data, and privacy should not be on the table as an economic good to be traded for convenience. Think one form of identification should not be the single key to my personal life and so on. 

If it helps explain it, I'm pretty opposed to DIDs at the moment. I want to own my data, but Id rather carry a briefcase around with my medical history from doc to doc rather than hold a key that just encrypts data on other peoples servers.  
 I would add to the first part to say that excessive integration of technology into culture is, in fact, anti-culture.  Culture is life-giving and creative, and technology, at its worst, drains our life and creativity.

Self-hosting is good.  If we're gonna use digital tech, it's good for us to have some modicum of ability and control with what goes on "behind the curtain" of the user interface. 
 Absolutely. I haven't evaluated the position of technology as antithetical to life and creativity. hmmm.  
 The overly simple motivation for me is: 

I hate going out in general public or in company with friends where there default reaction is to pull out their phone. Or being around phone zombies in general. College campus was bad, mostly with headphones and such. I enjoyed exchanging smiles, hellos, and how are you's to strangers, but most have headphones in or stare at screens. 

As an engineer I don't want to be responsible for endorsing, or encouraging what the world has become due to tech. I do wonder if there is such as thing as too much convenience, I mean I suppose there is always too much of something, but where there line is IDK.   
 Yeah we've collectively forgotten how to talk to strangers.  I'm often guilty of it as much as the next guy.

The attention to the consequences of your work as an engineer is commendable. 
 Also I'd argue it isn't really a general thing either. Plenty of older people 50s+ are just as bad or worse at this in my experience. Maybe not with a phone in their face, but equally awkward or bothered in public.  
 It's a skill.  I think part of that skill must come from taking in interesting and beautiful things, so that you can make meaningful conversation with people.

First, though, one needs a conversation starter and a bit of courage.  That takes practice. 
 Any tips? On the first part? 
 Not sure, as it's something I'm still learning.  Some ideas, though:

- Read a lot.  Fiction, nonfiction, essays, and occasional news.  Or if reading isn't always practical, podcasts and audio books do a pretty good job in the place of physical books.
- Talk about meaningful things with your friends.  Make connections.  Think about how the movie you just saw relates to the essay you just read.
- Engage in hobbies.  Something that interests you can you can get excited about with other people.
- Jog or garden or do something physical outside, that makes you attend to the weather, the skies, the seasons, and the natural world.
- Ask questions and listen.
- Laugh at other people's jokes, and at your own. 
 id love a simple qwerty + screen + wifi device just for typing and reading notes 
 Yeah, something that is just pretty dumb, where I don't have to work every day to make sure I'm not leaking privacy.  
 What Gigi describes seems to me well oriented towards lessening technology usage, at least as how I get your points... as I see it, a nsec, that is light to handle, transportable and even disposable, has the advantage of lessening the burden of logins, username-password accounts, craft and storage, etc, let's say, there's a engagement decrease (or at least alternative kind of interaction) with the devices... 
 In this specific technology case. 1. I think a single "password/key" as access to your entire life is an absolutely terrible idea. 2. for the majority of people that means your entire life on someone else's servers (which, yes, is how things are now, and it's bad) I don't think you should have enough, or really anything to lose on someone else's servers or even on your own phone. 

Technology is going to move forward with or without me, that's not lost on me, but I think there are simply some problems that should not be solved with technology, so I guess I'm arguing for caution? 
 1. Terrible because being a single point of failure? If so I agree. But also then, mitigation could be either to be cautious about what that key is securing, or managing a set of keys for specific purposes (although fair enough, we'd be back to square 1 in regards of device engagement 😅 )
With 2. I can't agree more as well. As for that matter nostr is also friendly towards running self hosting setups; that being said, self hosting could also be prone to single point of failure risks, ie, `centralizing' servers at home prone to $5 wrench's 🤔  
 I think since nostr just so many little components, I agree very self-hosting friendly. I've built my own signer and have a private relay (for testing) and so on. Self hosting is not cheap or easy, unless uptime isn't a big deal, so for sure. Anything that is too complicated for the average user to build/run risks centralization imo.