Oddbean new post about | logout
 #politics

How to collapse NATO:

Step 1: Turkey incites Israel, with rhetoric, supplying Israel's enemies, maybe even launches against them.
Step 2: Israel attacks Turkey (the 2nd most powerful NATO country)
Step 3: NATO countries now have to defend Turkey due to article 5
Step 4: USA breaks with NATO and defends Israel (of course they would)

There is no mechanism to expel a NATO member.
Turkey is very pro-Palestine and has threatened to invade Israel and forcibly keep the peace.
Putin would love to weaken or collapse NATO, and this lever has to be on his mind. 
 Israel won't attack Turkey but you do make a good point - Turkey doesn't belong in NATO

if Israel attacked Turkey it would be like USS Liberty all over again - the media would pretend it didn't happen 

and if Turkey attacked Israel pretty sure that would be reason enough for it to get expelled from NATO whether a mechanism exists or not

these organizations are only as good as political will backing them 
 if Turkey provides Hezbollah with material aid then family members of Erdogan will suddenly start having heart attacks and car accidents and the same will begin to happen to other senior members of government and military ...

there will be "terrorist attacks" in Turkey similar to September 11 in USA that nobody in the media will connect to Israel ...

Turkish airliners will start dropping like flies similar to how Israel has been blowing up Russian and Iranian planes carrying nuclear scientists ...

And on and on ... and everybody in the media will pretend like they have no clue who is doing it 

Basically your plan suggests that the smartest people on earth will do the stupidest things in order to shoot themselves in the foot - and then the good guys ( a.k.a. the dumb fucks ) can win !

sorry mate but not happening. 

back to the drawing board ! 
 your fundamental error is that you think like a member of Reality Based Community

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality-based_community

and that is just simply not how the world works

the way it works is the elites do whatever the fuck they want - there are no rules

and the people are told whatever bullshit the elites come up with - and the people swallow it all up

what you suggested is delusional almost on a level of believing that you can vote yourself out of tyranny

but i appreciate the entertainment value you bring to NOSTR - we could use more posters like you and @KenDBerryMD that make semi-intelligent posts which i can then take down point by point

by contrast other posters just say shit like "GM, stack sats and stay humble" which is so stupid it can't even be trolled.
 
 basically you and @KenDBerryMD are like punching bags that swing side to side and i can use to get a workout.

other posters on NOSTR are just dead horses - not worth beating.

in the past i would harass Lyn Alden because i thought she was cute and a good person ( even if a meme asset pumper ) but her failure to call out Israel for what it is has disgusted me so i unfollowed her.

now i just have you guys ! 
 Hmm interesting. They might try to blackmail or pressure in some other way Erdogan and the Turkish elites, but would def be interesting to see that happen. The US would prob be doing everything in its power to make sure that doesn't happen though.