Oddbean new post about | logout
 I understand that you or your kin can occasionally feel offended by some gross language. You know, it happens to me as well, and if I could learn to deal with it, and as you say, your wife could as well, everyone can. I can ignore it or respond kindly or rudely, whatever suits me best at the moment. It's my choice, and I don't want my choices to be limited either—it would be hypocritical to respond to a slur with a well deserved slur if I wanted to ban slurs altogether

The problem is that limiting free speech to get rid of the feeling of being offended (whether that was the speaker's intention or not) is wrong and dangerous.

It's the definition of a slur what bothers me most. Not only you can't read minds to decide what the intention was, but if you try, you inevitably gradually get to a place where even innocent humour is always offensive to someone and thus prohibited, where you get punished or intimidated even for offending someone unintentionally or where someone will misuse their claim of feeling offended to silence you.

I don't want to live in such a place. That's why I think it's way more important to learn to cope with offensive language that to get rid of it by the blunt force of the state or any other community power or social consensus applied by some authority. Let's just deal with it as individuals.

There is a very good article to the point here: https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/britain-isnt-a-free-country/ 
 Fucking amazing. 

Excellent response and sentiment. You've worded yourself very well and I couldn't agree more. 

I think you are 100% correct that we as individuals should learn how do deal with offensive language internally instead of imposing arbitrary rules on others to forcefully modify their speech. That dovetails nicely into my point about giving our power away to the language we use. 

I also find myself agreeing strongly with your point regarding intention in speech. It is impossible to discern another's intention which is what makes ideas like "microaggressions" absolutely absurd and unworkable.

Very good sir, I'm impressed with your articulation on this. Thank you for fleshing your thoughts out and sharing them. 

I appreciate you.