As Jack says, it depends… 

There are many great options these days, but each family has to find and decide which works best for them. My family is part of a Classical Conversations community, which is four days at home and then we meet with 25-30 families one day per week. Next year will be our 9th year, and it’s been a blessing for our family. We’ll homeschool through high school. That said, there is no wrong choice if you’re building lasting relationships with your kids and instilling character and virtue - and all of that is easier to do when the pedagogy prioritizes truth, goodness, and beauty.