Do i ever have a story for you.  Basically same story,  but he took our carry and vaxxed/ chipped it.  Cat came back after a month three days ago. He is demanding $500 or he said they'll take us to court and have the cops come remove the cat.  This is next level 'crazy cat' guy.  He had painted black finger nails :) i think I'll just ignore him and see what happens 

 What a dick