send ["OK",false,"auth-required: blah"] should be enough, i forget exactly, but the client has to expect that and queue the request to send it out after doing the auth and getting the OK true

i forget how the CLOSE envelope plays into it, but i do know that replicatr does it correctly, lemme dig it up...

no, it's CLOSED envelope:

https://github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr/blob/main/app/auth.go

and then after that you send the AUTH envelope with the challenge to the client

and here is my client side code, this shoud help the client devs a bit at least:

this is a simple auth tester:

https://github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr/blob/main/cmd/authr/authr.go

this shows how it's used in a client (this one can auth to two relays and pull from one and push to the other):

https://github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr/blob/main/cmd/ingestr/app/ingest.go

of course nobody pays attention to me, but i've actually written both sides of it, fiatjaf wrote some fragments of parts of it but i wasn't able to find anything that actually demonstrated how to string it together

yes, this works with coracle btw on the client side

hell, replicatr works perfectly as a relay except after about 24 hours it has some weird resource leak that eats CPU that's why it isn't in production 

 if you can find it and fix it i'll pay a reasonable amount of sats for doing it, it's embarrassing that i couldn't find that bastard thing... it's instrumented with profiling and runtime configuration settings and everything, drove me nuts 

 most likely i made the bug, also, but probably thanks to how convoluted fiatjaf's goroutine spawning is written 

 I am pretty sure auth is working I tested with a bunch of clients and use it with ndk, but the mystery of the giftwraps.  I tried your tool, it has mleku.net deps still lingering I can't build it. 

 ah crap, i better fix that tomorrow

not sure why you aren't getting them from the go module proxy cache tho

yeah, tomorrow...

i'm currently working on a count encoder that appends to a buffer you pass it so you can reuse the buffer 

 i'm getting that done now btw, just running tests after moving all the required content into place so it's a monorepo then i'll check that everything in cmd and the root build correctly also, won't be long (one of the tests runs for a while haha) 

 it's done btw, you should now be able to do like 

go install github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr/cmd/ingestr

and have it pull and build it, anyhow, it's there, i needed to fix it, i forgot it was totally broken 

 go install github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr/cmd/ingestr@latest

lol 

 go install github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr/cmd/ingestr@v1.2.17

better still, that is the actually what i just built now

me@iox:/src/github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr$ ingestr
Usage: ingestr [--nsec NSEC] [--since SINCE] [--limit LIMIT] [--interval INTERVAL] [--pause PAUSE] [--follows FOLLOWS] DOWNLOADRELAY UPLOADRELAY
error: downloadrelay is required
 

 Thanks man, ya I found my bug.  String instead of bool. 🤦‍♂️ 

 i saw that, was just thinking maybe something in that stuff might have helped with the auth flow is all 

 see my response, i wrote all this stuff, i know it works, it auths on nostrudel and coracle, just the damn resource bug

it's at https://github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr in cmd/ingestr for client side, anyway, just check my other note

here: nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzqnyqqft6tz9g9pyaqjvp0s4a4tvcfvj6gkke7mddvmj86w68uwe0qqszeyrlj2mcvggjzp2y9np52eyq4yjxu09wzzyret7zvqxskflcthsv9prp8 

 just to repeat, replicatr is not ok for production, it has a resource leak bug that i couldn't squash in a month of hunting it 

 https://github.com/Hubmakerlabs/replicatr this should build for you now, i pulled in all those dependencies and made it a monorepo

was pretty funny running it again... had all the configurations and a database already sitting on my disk and just fires right up

anyhow, please reply if you get any errors with it now, i'm pretty sure i didn't exclude anything in the allowlist .gitignore but i buggered up the precomps in my revised embed version elsewhere

(yeah, this whole mess happened because i kept getting git bugs and gave up self hosting after i had mleku.net/reponame as i wanted using legit but gd fkn git buggerization, haven't heard from the legit dev yet about a fix on it i filed an issue) 

 Hey Mike, ya the relay tester was right.  I deployed a fix to change the string to bool and the auth test proceeded.  Whew, relay tester ftw!! 💎 

 did you verify that it is a "CLOSED" envelope its supposed to send first then "AUTH" with challenge after? (and expect an AUTH with signed event containing challenge... in the content field??? i think? no, i think in the tag after "challenge") 

 https://github.com/nostr-protocol/nips/blob/master/42.md#protocol-flow

yeah, that's the info there anyhow 

 Did you run my https://github.com/mikedilger/relay-tester or are you referring to me as your "relay tester"?  😂 

 Yes I ran it lmao!!! 😂😎👨‍💻