Oddbean new post about login | logout 3 images, two are biopersons, shot by a biphotographer the other one is generated by OpenAI Sora model...but which one 😉 https://image.nostr.build/54374f022138941cf41caf62ca9f388f60f26d002f4e7892449dd5aeae70161f.jpg https://image.nostr.build/b2dd6d5933cd5f9975f2b45dc24826f2c26d022d2b39ceacc013faa3772d74aa.jpg https://image.nostr.build/2451b44aba3d1b7fde7122789cc5bc6ff018f020c15393de82e1c720892c34f0.jpg
First is real, 2-3 are ai?
Nope 🫠 1,3 - real 2 - the one without makeup is Sora AI
That’s what I guessed! Because of the shadow below the cap and you can see hair shimmering over the cap
Crazy how there are some clues but you really have to be focused to spot them 🫠
AI is just recreating things. It has no basic understanding of things. If you have this in mind you can always find some clues if an image is AI generated
second is ai because of funny looking (very tiny) pupil https://m.primal.net/HdZv.jpg
well done but it was a very hard guess i dont know if would have chosen the right picture
it was zoomed out but the pupils look unnatural and seems to be copy paste of a chocolate whale candy snack https://m.primal.net/HdZw.jpg
The fact one has to carefully look for the ai artefacts to distinguish the AI one is quite impressive. In a year humans probably won't be realiably able to tell what's what in most cases. By that time the movement in videos will also become sorta convincing. Photos taken by smartphones are "fake" for a long time. Now AI will take it much further. The output of the smartphone photography will be increasingly an AI interpretation of a complex data captured in a brief moment. "Raw" photos from dedicated pro cameras will look amateurish in comparison unless an absolute master uses it (often with extra lights/flashes etc). If there still was some reason to use dedicated consumer/prosumer cameras up to this point... they are 💀 in a few years.
Actually, I predict that there will be a growing demand for real images and reputations will be made for offering those exclusively
As a niche yes.
Third is AI. I think...
the third photo the OpenAI?
I think 2 is ai. Or even number 1. Bottom line I have no clue really
Yes! 2 🙂
Hard to tell. The last one either has some over-sharpening done in Photoshop or it’s the AI one. The depth of field of the foreground objects looks weird as well.
Just number 2, the other ones are from photographers 🙂 https://image.nostr.build/386337e800bb53b11631cd13c77dcfbeb8271603668c977ac500622a455fb0f8.jpg
Wow, even the reflection of the eyelashes on the iris/pupil.
That’s crazy … it’s hard to tell even if you know it (i.e. from hairs coming out of her beanie). On the other hand even regular photos are created with software these days and have artificial portrait effects, post processing and the like.
These are what make me think ai gen. Wrinkle is not bio and that hair curl defies physics But golly that's incredible Now combine it with 3d model generation 🤯 https://image.nostr.build/c586be6d6a0c4d52c319fa9c63af82ed05341c9a6e42cbc8e3f696c2f0655b41.jpg
the blone is the real one.
Also what this means for "photographic evidence". And I don't mean online, I mean when someone breaks into your property and you take photos for the insurance company. Or if you are acused of something and you need to proove your inocence... ... and what ifthe only evidence that you have is heavily AI processed photo taken at a critical moment, because that's the setting that was on the camera at that point. Or maybe there is no unprocessed mode in the camera and it censors what you can take picture of. "I'm sorry, I can't take a picture, do you want the illegal bits to be replaced by black bars or perhaps flowers?"
Some kind of cryptographic tech together with a "forensic/clean mode" could help though.
Number 2 with the knit hat is AI
#YESTR 👍
Haha nice 😂 Incredibly realistic image though.
If you don't stop to look closely you don't notice it, brain fast checks it as real https://image.nostr.build/386337e800bb53b11631cd13c77dcfbeb8271603668c977ac500622a455fb0f8.jpg
💯
