Is the new wallet also NWC? 
If yes, you need to setup a new NWC string for the mew wallet. 
If not, there should be a wallet selector in the settings of Amethyst. Whenever you zap the wallet should open to allow you to pursue with the zap 

 Thanks😊 

 https://media1.tenor.com/m/UladBrWhuJ8AAAAC/bowing-thank-you.gif