Oddbean new post about | logout

Notes by dcb6bba5 | export

 There is no point in having a Nostr protocol if end-users are never aware of it in some way. 
 Marketing is a swing, and a miss for nostr atm. Hopefully that will change at some point. There has to be a focus on what an end user demands. A quick example of how my business dealt with market demands. My industry is riddled with poor customer service. We read all the bad reviews for companies in our area, and %90 of them were poor customer service. Bad reviews aren’t just people gripping about a company. It’s potential clients telling an industry what they want from an industry. Address that, and you’re king in your industry. You offered something that people want. Does Nostr provide something people want?  How much market research has been done to find out what most potential end users want?  I wouldn’t expect much, or enough has been done tbh. I wouldn’t expect most would care much about privacy, bitcoin, censorship free, or a whole lot of what Nostr provides. That’s not to say those aren’t important. It is to say that if Nostr wants success to a point that it competes then keep all that is good already with Nostr, but more focus should be placed on what  end user demands are. So outside of the Nostr bubble what are people talking about with social media?  What are there complaints, what do they like. What would they improve?  The largest number of those people probably don’t care about what Nostr is currently offering. Nostr needs to know what those people care about, and do that where it doesn’t interfere with its foundational principles. 
You can’t just say it’s superior so everyone will use it. Thats not how things work. I’m a pretty bad ass classical guitarist, but none of you knew that, and a lot of you might not believe me, because I didn’t market myself as such, and who likes classical guitar anyways. Some do for sure, but I’m not grabbing millions of views with it. I might do better to transpose some classical guitar songs over to an instrument that would be more appealing if I were to want a bigger audience, or I might do, and really I am doing in a since what nostr is doing. Just Jamin in my backyard hoping the neighbors will hear me, and call Carnegie Hall to tell them they really need me.   
 Community relays are a bad idea

Community relays get mentioned a lot as a solution to spam or il... 
 I’m not extremely familiar with the technology behind Nostr. I’m just a dude trying to entertain myself. So I have no clue about how to implement anything. I do know that I don’t really care about bitcoin, or dev speak, and that’s a majority of what I see on any Nostr client. I absolutely love the privacy, and decentralized aspect of Nostr, but the content kinda sucks from the perspective of the majority of us that don’t really care about the topics that are proliferated on every client. Thats a major limiting factor for the success of Nostr. It will be tough to grow any client to a substantial user base with limited content. It will be what it is today a niche that hits a wall that it can’t grow beyond. Without the ability for the user to curate content you won’t grab enough users to build anything that competes in any way with centralized social media. Communities don’t come without there draw backs for sure, but likewise neither to generic relays. For me I jump into Nostr clients about once every six months to see if anything appeals to me hoping, and praying something will, and immediately get thrown right back into the same bitcoin, and dev speak content I don’t really care about, and then bail for another 6 months. Many won’t be as little committed as I am. Many will jump in, dislike the content, leave, and never return. There has to be an answer to that that can be implemented in a marketable way. Basically in a way that an 80 year old grandma can implement with little effort, and enjoy doing. Without that nostr social media clients are doomed to a small nice audience of bitcoiners, and developers. I’m extremely interested in nostr for my own reason, and perpetually let down by it at the same time, and I am the majority of potential users you lose with generic relays.