Oddbean new post about | logout
 Can you name some conflicts/wars/political contests where the bad guys actually won (though they wrote the history to paint themselves as the good guys, of course)?

#asknostr 
 2nd American War of Secession

The Great Patriotic War 
 Which war are you calling the "Great Patriotic War"? 

The "2nd American War of Secession" would be the so-called Civil War, right? 
 It's the Russian name for WW2

And yes, I would count colonies vs crown & dixie vs yankees as American wars of secession, although I suppose there's an argument to make for Texian secession being largely American as well 
 In the American context I would add the Nationalists/Federalists beating out the so-called "Anti-federalists" to get the Constitution adopted.

But then there are also many elections that could be named as well (1860, 1876, 1912, 1916, 1964, 2020)... 
 I was just thinking of war (despite your initial question)

IMO the most calamitous US election was 1896, in which the conservative, free trade party (Democrats) was taken over and we haven't really had a proper conservative party ever since (although of course the GOP is closer to it than modern Dems) 
 ahhhh all of them ? 
 the story of the "war in heaven" has been pretty polluted 
 What's your source for this story? The Book of Enoch? It's not in the Bible, though people think it is... 
 the war in heaven is in the bible, i forget which book, exodus maybe?

in a different form but a lot of correspondences it's found in the Vishnu Purana as well

the ancient greeks called it the Titanomachy, the war of the titans, and the titans claimed to have won it but that isn't true because they turned tail and sailed off around africa counterclockwise and ended up in the red sea and invaded the peoples there (this all is around 15,000 years ago btw, before the mini ice age that was the younger dryas)

i'm pretty sure it's in sumerian mythology and babylonian and almost everywhere, and many versions especially by the cultures that were invaded by these ass-pirates in the now middle east (was lush green land then, before the fly-by of a meteor that blew up over the atlantic) and established the first modern tyrannical monarchies, and started the "mandate of heaven" or "divine right of kings" perversions 
 You're right, I recall now war in heaven is mentioned in Revelation 12. But it's a matter of interpretation as to when that war occurred and what specifically it is talking about.

Interesting stuff you're talking about there, regarding human history that took place over 15,000 years ago. I've heard of the Younger-Dryas theory, but I need to read up more on it. When you go back much more than 5,000 years you get into pre-history, before any surviving written texts, so I'm not sure about the sources of the information concerning what happened prior. 
 you need to read The Apocalypse of Yajnavalkya

and it is absolutely loaded with references related to recent discoveries, it was only published in early 2023 and it is VERY current

you will agree with the hypothesis once you read through about 1/4 of that book 
 I was thinking you were going to refer me to Graham Hancock. I've heard he has produced some books and shows related to Younger-Dryas and very ancient Earth history. 
 possibly it's a pseudonym but i think it's a lot more comprehensive than what i've heard about hancock

my sense is it's someone who studies all of these things intensely and is their first  book, someone very clever and careful 
 Hatfields and McCoys?