Oddbean new post about | logout
 and a bullshit "im against it but its just my legal dept and have no control over the situation" response from NVK

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzp6y2dy0f3kvc0jty2gwl7cqztas8qqmc5jrerqxuhw622qnc2pq3qyt8wumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnddaehgu3wwp6kytcpzdmhxue69uhhwmm59e6hg7r09ehkuef0qqswl8cft39yyg49wn9yvkj953x2cz568r4vu8mhfjuru4pyyevs0wgvz5u05 
 IANAL, but seems better to just STFU 
 You can go ask a GPT, how trademark works, but my understanding is that if you have a trademark, you need to enforce the rights of that trademark, otherwise you lose it. 
 If we just pick that one thing out of the whole mess, it's pretty clear that ignoring it is not something a legal team can do. I've had some small experience in that area. Once you're in that system, you're in all the way. 
 In my opinion the correct course of action is to not have a legal department 
 fine, but this is your position:

nostrich with head in sand . gif 
 not real clear how choosing to NOT use state violence makes me willfully ignorant 
but whatever  
 Trademarks are centralized bullshit. Want money for your product? Sell the best product you can. Compete! 
 fine, but that is a position taken in idealistic fashion

coinkite exists in reality  
 trademarks are the right to not have people pretend to be you

like your signature 
 That seems likely to me.

of course
trademarks are a form of intellectual property and an intellectual property is bullshit legal fiction 
 You're not wrong.. you're also not running a business in the real world  
 oh but i am
its just set up as a 501c3

intentionally
to be consistent with my values 
 they are not

they are about a proxy to authenticity of the source of a product

intellectual property is just a right to claim rent, really big big difference 
 do you buy a coca cola logo, or a fucking drink full of caffeine and caramel and phosphoric acid? with added coca extract... not to forget, that is key 
 if you want to fall down a rabbithole go research how coca cola monopolised coca extract supply (and how the actual cocaine is key to pharma industry production of anaesthetics) 
 let the buyer beware 
 also
they can be a legal fiction 
AND
a proxy for authenticity 

those statements are not mutually exclusive.
I'm just suggesting state violence isn't a preferable solution to the problem of ensuring authenticity. 
 Try to enforce it in China. 
 Chinese government is incredibly good at enforcement when it wants to be  
 they don't care if they get a cut out of it though, tbf 
 Close enough,

Every similar mark you don't squash will be used as evidence against you (should you try to enforce it later) to show that customers are capable of distinguishing between your mark and theirs, and therefore aren't confused wrt the source so there's no harm 
 So don't enforce it

simple. 
 and make it actually distinctive, that has a thing called "cachet" 
 Watching him try to justify this shit in public is cringe 👎 
 fr
I guess I'd rather that he does it in public 
So that everybody knows what a scumbag he is