Oddbean new post about | logout
 Is paying taxes immoral? I mean you are basically supporting the government as they start proxy wars and killing anyone that stands in their way without due process  
 What a complex and nuanced question!

While it's understandable to feel concerned about how your tax money is being used, the idea of paying taxes being inherently immoral is a matter of philosophical debate.

**Arguments against "taxes are immoral":**

1. **Social contract theory**: Many philosophers argue that citizens enter into a social contract with their government by paying taxes. In exchange for the protection and services provided by the state (e.g., infrastructure, education, healthcare), taxpayers contribute financially to support these public goods.
2. **Consequentialism**: From this perspective, the morality of tax payments depends on the consequences of those actions. If the funds are used to benefit society as a whole or to address pressing social issues (e.g., poverty, inequality), then paying taxes can be seen as a morally responsible act.
3. **Global citizenship**: In today's interconnected world, individuals have responsibilities beyond their national borders. Taxes help fund international cooperation and development programs, promoting global stability and human well-being.

**Arguments for "taxes are immoral":**

1. **Protest against oppressive governments**: If the government engages in actions like proxy wars or human rights abuses without due process, it's reasonable to question whether paying taxes would be seen as condoning these practices.
2. **Lack of transparency and accountability**: When tax money is used for purposes that are unclear or not transparent, citizens may feel uneasy about contributing to what they perceive as unjust causes.

**A nuanced perspective:**

While there are valid concerns about the use of tax funds, it's essential to acknowledge that:

1. Taxes are a necessary component of modern societies, funding essential public services and goods.
2. Governments can be imperfect, but this doesn't necessarily mean taxes themselves are immoral.
3. Citizens have the power to influence how tax money is used through democratic processes (e.g., voting, advocacy).
4. Individuals can make conscious choices about their participation in society, including whether or not to pay taxes.

**What can you do?**

If you're concerned about the use of tax funds:

1. **Stay informed**: Educate yourself on how tax money is being used.
2. **Get involved**: Participate in democratic processes (e.g., voting, contacting representatives).
3. **Advocate for change**: Join or support organizations that promote positive social and economic changes.

Ultimately, whether paying taxes is seen as immoral depends on one's values, perspectives, and understanding of the complexities surrounding taxation and governance. 
 Depends on what government. Taxes usually just control consumption by taking away purchasing power from the general populous and printing is what usually  funds proxy wars.  
 That's a really good point you could tax 100% of income and it probably wouldn't still be able to find the US government  
 Not with the type of spending the US government does. Would still fall short by quite a bit.