Oddbean new post about | logout
 Pretty sure that’s what the scum bags at primal are doing. 
 Oh. This wasn't about Primal. Though they could be. So could nostr.wine, nostr.band, and NostrPlebs via noswhere.com. Anyone that indexes data could do this. Maybe we need a data policy to say that we're not. 🤔 
 At Primal, we index Nostr data for the sole purpose of providing discovery features to our users. 

Our entire software stack is open under the MIT license. That means that anyone can use our software to do exactly the same thing we are doing. I believe that our indexer is the only open source indexer on Nostr; please correct me if I am wrong. 

It should be understood that Nostr is a radically open network. The social graph and all published data are publicly visible by everyone. Running an indexer is not hard, so I don’t think that “selling this data to advertising agencies” will be a competitive business. Anyone who wants to have this data will have it easily enough.  
 On the other hand, advertizer could run free relays to ammulate data without implementing a relay. Then they can do real-time advertising by trying to buy out client authors with lucrative money. 
 Hi, I was wondering if you could explain how sats are built into the stack pls. How does it flow from primal to nostr to lightening to base layer ? Thank you 
 Wow, that’s harsh. 😂🤣

Why call us scum bags? We build open source software and run services for Nostr. We never attacked another project. 🤷‍♂️ 
 Don’t play dumb! 
 Policy complete. 🤝