How Streaming Services train you for Obedience With novel ways of thinking about propaganda and obedience training, this short post will recommend: a) stop watching television b) stop streaming services c) stop Spotify/music streaming Television not only rots your brain with low level dribble, but you are a passive consumer. The goal of television is to force-feed you content, instead of having you actively decide or evaluate choices. This trains you to accept authority, as eventually the two choices can turn to one. In his famous book from 1928 titled “Propaganda”, Edward Bernays, who produced media for the United Fruit Company (and therefore the CIA), to overthrow Latin American governments, pushed the idea that propaganda ought to reduce the choices the consumer make. He promoted the idea that propaganda should push the consumer down to binary thinking. [1] Even if you were to decide between things to torrent on your PC, that would be better than just turning on the TV and consuming whatever is on. Because torrents force you to research options from an infinite dataset and then make a choice, which is training your mind to question and consider alternatives. By using streaming services, it creates a cycle of dependence on the provider and the elimination of your privacy. Streaming services force Digital Rights Management (DRM), which is insecure technology that uproots the autonomy of your electronics to become an obedient receiver of commands from the media company, in order to ensure copyright compliance. While this seems like a trivial matter, DRM represents a fundamental shift in the dynamics of power, to have electronics that you own, become subservient to a master other than you. Furthermore, you open yourself up to security vulnerabilities as hackers try to uplift this new-found foreign power. According to Monero core developer ArticMine, DRM is so insecure, that he does not even trust American cybersecurity firms to diagnose vulnerabilities, because they can’t legally break DRM. Instead, he says it’s a shame that war has prevented the use of Russian companies that can properly diagnose problems. [2] Services like Spotify reduce the need to research musicians on your own. You accept whatever the popular choices are for a genre and avoid making decisions on what comes next. Furthermore, Spotify and music streaming services like it, reduce the need to interact with others. When I was a teenager, asking other kids what music they liked was how I did research. This made the process of exploration into an activity into itself. Today, you’re hooked into what the AI predicts you’re least likely to close the app after a few seconds if they put on. This merges your unique independent tastes into whatever appeals to the most people who are consuming. Sources: https://simplifiedprivacy.com/stream/
You can turn off suggested music automatically playing on Spotify, and I do. I also like following friends on there and have picked up interesting music leads from their playlists and realtime listening. None of this prohibits me from talking to them about music or researching on my own in other ways. Most of my life, I’ve had zero friends who shared my music taste, so asking them for advice would have made my listening much more mainstream. Before I had Spotify, I did most of my music research through YouTube, which is arguably much more algorithmic. But instead of directing me to popular channels, I used it to find even weirder, more niche stuff than I already listened to 😂 These things are just tools. It’s our job to have awareness and use the tool rather than let it use us.
ok ok. yes the tools are what you make of them.
Tools I used to curate my own info-stream: . RSS feeds to efficiently read blogs/substacks and subscribe to video channels . yt-dlp to throw videos on my phone as .mp3's for listening while doing chores. . yt-dlp for saving documentaries to local storage . podcastindex.org . nostr
Thank you for making me feel good about pirating stuff ;)
nostr:note1qqqqqdl6q2f67v0h32z6h2f3jj47gntwkmvnymj9k0vz72nrwyjsc9w646 I have often thought about this. Not specifically the obedience aspect. More about how I have noticed that I don't enjoy music as I used to. I have wondered if, at least in part, that having unfettered access to music has in a way cheapened it. I remember that I used to buy an album, and I would listen to it for weeks and weeks. Now I churn though music. Granted I could just pace myself, but the platforms do not lend themselves to this kind of behavior IMO. Discovery is different too. It was a skill, maybe even an art, that each person has to develop. Now we don't, or at least I feel I don't have to anymore. The question is: is that a reflection on me or the tech?