Oddbean

Here are things I currently believe about Hamas that I also see as negative. Until recently their stated organizational goal included killing all Jews everywhere. They may be using unwilling civilians as shields. They killed children intentionally during the Oct 7 events. They killed non-combatant men and women intentionally during the same. They may be restricting people from fleeing from Gaza. Their stated strategy is to cause Israel to kill civilians (who have seemingly not consented meaningfully to be so sacrificed) in order to rally support against Israel. For sure maybe these are not true.

Ok, so before even addressing these points, the fundamental question is, if these points were misinformation, deliberately via propaganda or accidental via misunderstanding, if they weren’t true, how would that change your view of this conflict? Because if it changes nothing, then it’s a pointless to the discussion by even mentioning it.

Yeah so let’s say that all my moral problems with a Hamas are proven false, new more valid ones don’t appear, and that a similar review of Israel doesn’t exonerate Israel, then that would shift things for me dramatically. My intention with my opinion is to be true, with no preference for the typical goal of it staying the same as it has been. Clarifying, dor me right now it’s mostly a question of do I think its best for the area to stop being be under the kind of Israeli government control it’s under after or before Hamas is defeated.

I think you’re a reasonable man, and given the information I trust you will come to a conclusion that is more reflective of the facts. I genuinely suggest, sincerely from my heart, that you just watch the video I shared above with Norman Fincklstine, a Jewish scholar in this field. He’s not a Muslim or Hamas so hopefully that would eliminate the suspicion of bias. Watch that; and let me know how you feel after. To address in brief, 1) Regarding the lies about mass rape, that’s received an Uber push just over the last few days, total lies, as can be seen here. They even used picture from wars in Kurdistan as evidence of Hamas. Lies https://youtu.be/pMqRK5LpGy4?feature=shared 2) The babies, also lies, debunked here also here and plenty of other places https://youtu.be/jUA74ws4NPs?si=d_fQQz0-E1nX90SC 3) The human shields has also been debunked for over a decade now, with no independent organisation every been able to verify that, while all alone independent orgs have proven that Israel has been using human shields for decades now. If you want evidence for this just ask, but I think Norman addresses this 4) They prevent people leaving Gaza, not true, and again, where is the Independent evidence for this? 5) Killing non-combatant men and women, like I said, there were a lot of people who died as a result of the military operation. But there is strong evidence that they weren’t intentional if it occurred. But remember, these places were fortified military locations, even if there were civilians living there. And a civilian who picks up a weapon is now a combatant under international law by the way. Again, if you want evidence for this I can get it. But here is the evidence that the Israelis killed their own people on the 7th https://x.com/ecomarxi/status/1732022607791145273?s=46&t=AeUubJVXjsWeffPXQIjUGA And: https://x.com/propandco/status/1732134983806914940?s=46&t=AeUubJVXjsWeffPXQIjUGA I sincerely request you give Norman a go. He explains it better than me, being a scholar in this. https://image.nostr.build/888a87ea4e0a5d46120545693ed09b95eb1892b682e76b8bf3e8b24da7f2361e.jpg

One last point forgot to mention which actually is the most important one 😂 No, Hamas and no Muslim, wants to kill all Jews. This is either a mistranslation, misunderstanding or outright lie. Most likely what was said was to remove the Jews in power from Palestine, the occupied lands, but it does not include a ‘holocaust like’ death cult. This is so opposed to Islam that it would be tantamount to a form of disbelief in Islam itself. Allah says in the Quraan لَّا یَنۡهَىٰكُمُ ٱللَّهُ عَنِ ٱلَّذِینَ لَمۡ یُقَـٰتِلُوكُمۡ فِی ٱلدِّینِ وَلَمۡ یُخۡرِجُوكُم مِّن دِیَـٰرِكُمۡ أَن تَبَرُّوهُمۡ وَتُقۡسِطُوۤا۟ إِلَیۡهِمۡۚ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ یُحِبُّ ٱلۡمُقۡسِطِینَ﴿ ٨ ﴾ and He does not forbid you to deal kindly and justly with anyone who has not fought you for your faith or driven you out of your homes: God loves the just. Al-Mumtaḥanah, Ayah 8 إِنَّمَا یَنۡهَىٰكُمُ ٱللَّهُ عَنِ ٱلَّذِینَ قَـٰتَلُوكُمۡ فِی ٱلدِّینِ وَأَخۡرَجُوكُم مِّن دِیَـٰرِكُمۡ وَظَـٰهَرُوا۟ عَلَىٰۤ إِخۡرَاجِكُمۡ أَن تَوَلَّوۡهُمۡۚ وَمَن یَتَوَلَّهُمۡ فَأُو۟لَـٰۤىِٕكَ هُمُ ٱلظَّـٰلِمُونَ﴿ ٩ ﴾ But God forbids you to take as allies those who have fought against you for your faith, driven you out of your homes, and helped others to drive you out: any of you who take them as allies will truly be wrongdoers. Al-Mumtaḥanah, Ayah 9 So as you can see, non-oppressive Jews are protected and left alone. Our grief is only with those who oppress Muslims; kill us and kick us out of our homes. Hamas could never have such stupid beliefs, and no Muslim in the history of Islam has ever had that type of beliefs.

Now you’re being dogmatic 😂 Why does the world have to operate under your legal ideology? There are multiple ways in which a nation can rightly operate that does happen to be a carbon copy of the west.

🫂 I haven’t introduced myself it seems :) I don’t think it should be anything like the west. That’s why I am a proponent of a 0 state solution. Of course the world doesn’t have to operate under what I happen to think is the ideally moral system. Democracy btw is not my ideal system either. Democracy is just better in my view what I fear Hamas is doing - a sort of secret governing body that is not accountable to its people, can’t be unseated by them without violence, and doesn’t let them live there without being under their rule and paying tribute to them. But if the question is “which side do I think should be go away first”, which is how I think of the question here, then sure my ideology is important.