Oddbean new post about | logout
 Pkarr was suggested to Nostr people probably a year ago or so. We have been working on our vision for the web since before Nostr existed, and we created Pubky to be what we think is the best design. So why should we retrofit it to Nostr conventions and make it worse again? Why should we be spending 2 years lobbying people to do make fundamental changes they do not want ro make? You see this all thru a lens of Nostr but it just isnt our world really. Its like asking us to make it more like Mastodon or Hypercore, no, we made it this way in purpose and we have great reasons for it.

Regarding DHT scale, it used for dns records, and it is very fast and larger than any other decentralized network, so it is weird to be casting doubt from beneath its shadow, no? Yes, all networks hit scaling challenges, but this is why we designed Pubky to put the user in control, to allow for central service in a safer way.

Why do you think we are claiming something prior to our own brand? We literally list every single alternative in the post as well as explain exactly what we do differently and how we use Mainline. 

We are just another group of people with our own ideas about how to fix the web, we dont really owe nostr anything, but we are happy to engage with interested users and devs. It is what it is. 
 > Pkarr was suggested to Nostr people probably a year ago or so. 

Can you link to a conversation? I don't see anything on the nips repo. I can imagine why nostr devs would be resistant. But my point is that you don't have to ask for permission to build on nostr, you could just do it, then say "hey, look how well this works".

It's also fair that if you've had all this in the works since before nostr then you could say the same about us having NIH syndrome. But it's at least interesting that the momentum went with nostr, not slashtags. Maybe that's down to Jack Dorsey, but I think there's more to it than that. That's all on the social level, but you should at least ask why people are building on nostr and not discount it.

My point about DHTs is just limited to p2p networks. DNS doesn't really require that scale, and it seems like pubky also allows for shared network infrastructure, so it may be irrelevant. Nostr relays are really just ad-hoc DHTs, so it's more about how they're used than the technology itself. 
 tons of private conversations with Fiatjaf, and I showed it to Strfry maintainer in private too, and wrote about it here for a year and

https://primal.net/e/note18q4yrj5m2ekvkceq7qn3zqrsxf2w6uq0az2rp867hvz4p5r74wxsa2xchl