I need your opinion. 

When you are on Amethyst's the main feed (not in a thread) and you click reply in a post, write your message and post, should Amethyst: 

1. Redirect you to view that thread and show your reply OR 
2. Stay in the main feed to quickly move to the next topic? 

1 or 2? 

1 shows the confirmation that your post is there.
2 allows faster replies in many posts.