Oddbean new post about | logout
 Is what they're saying about the DSA wrong then? I'd honestly never heard of it. 
 I've gotten two of these mails and still do not understand what they're asking me.

So I see three options:
1. they're just bad at explaining; or
2. their lawyers told them to keep it vague; or
3. they're doing malicious compliance and/or lobbying by making it intentionally confusing, so authors and publishers blame the EU

(3) would then help them with other aspects of DSA that are unrelated to books.

If I had to bet it's (1) though - the iBooks department is probably too low on their list of things to spend any attention on, so they don't bother making this compliance step easy to understand. 
 I mean: a what does "trader" mean here? I wrote a book. I paid for my editor and other things as a business expense, so I consider royalties to be revenue. Does that make me a "trader"? What even is that? Why does the EU want to know that? 
 Doesn't it point you to a link that's supposed to help you decide if you're a trader or not? 
 Oh yes! https://itunespartner.apple.com/books/support/5401-manage-digital-services-act-compliance-information#trader

(which about as helpful as the email, even linking to the EU page about the entire DSA) 
 Oh yes! https://itunespartner.apple.com/books/support/5401-manage-digital-services-act-compliance-information#trader

(which about as helpful as the email, even linking to the EU page about the entire DSA) nostr.fmt.wiz.biz 
 > Trader self assessment: Find information about how to know if you are a trad

Leads to:

> Apple can’t determine whether you’re a trader.

And:

> To determine if you’re a trader, you should consider a range of non-exhaustive and non-exclusive factors (see those listed on page 2 in the EC’s Guidance), which may include .... 
 Would you say this is bad on the part of the EU or Apple though? I don't really know anything about this. 
 I don't know, that's what I was asking about.

In any case if the answer were "yes" (trader) then Apple has to doxx me. So I'd remove the book in that case.