Well the issue is that yugioh fundamentally is a bandaid game. It wasn't designed as a real game to be played in real life. Bandaid solutions are applied constantly until you get what we have now. I genuinely don't understand why they don't do format rotations and just keep the current format with the crazy ban list as a secondary format as people clearly don't like it. It's one thing if you're a new game and scared of rotations (rotations usually kill games that aren't heavily prepared for it) but I seriously doubt it would hurt yugioh.