Oddbean new post about | logout
 So WTF are we gunna do about reply guy. New npubs all the time now. Banning won't work. #asknostr #dev  
 No puedo frenarlo 🫤😡 
 I don’t see reply guy on Damus. Only on Primal. 
 they’re all over my damus :( 
 I have blocked maybe 12 accounts total 
 me too. it’s getting rough out here for a real life actual human 
 ? We get a new one of these every few months. This one isn't even questionable content. It will pass 
 I've blocked dozens 
 If I reply to this, am I a reply guy? What is a reply guy? 
 this reply marked safe from GM reply guy 
 😂 
 I don't log IPs on my relays, but shit like this almost makes me want to, just to see if it's coming from the same IP address. 
 I log IP on grain. It will be banned on my relay soon if a solution is not found. I will make it known when I do. Still only a temporary measure as that can be changed with a VPN fairly quickly  
 Right its only more whack-a-mole.  
 For half a second I was thinking that auth on relays would fix this, but I don't think that would fix it either. Even if it was free to authenticate on a relay, whoever is writing with spam bots can just have the new profile authenticate before making a new npub making that pointless. 
 😂 nostr protocol isn’t protected 
 Add the string "GM, from wss" to your security filter. 

Relay operators could also filter and block that string too.  
 Nip-42 auth prevents this 
 term mute "GM" ez 
 That's a bit drastic at the moment. 
 I like it because I also don't care when real people say it either 
 Paid relays.  
 Or even invite-only relays where the admin can see who invited who 
 Amethyst muted words: ReplyGuy
💨 
 I can't see my post because it worked! 
 Awesome. I thought it only worked for note content! Problem solved.  
 filter on content 
 I'm sure this will be the first of many. 

Mute words can be bypassed by generating random text if needed
IP address blocking really doesn't solve it, proxies, vpn etc
Keys can be generated on demand

It's just a DOS in a way as it looks like regular content. 

Paid relays help but we still have freelays for now so as long as relays federate content, may be an issue due to replies. 
 
 i did this this morning
not a great solution 😕 https://image.nostr.build/9579cc599f7768c6eb960ee0a1e42e5515dfb00ce5d089e59123eb68a1eaeb6c.jpg 
 > not a great solution
why ? 
 because the relays still are dealing with spam?

or because they just change the reply text and keep going? 
 it got worse, now they are copying the notes ! 
 Filter by web-of-trust 
 Will you expand on this? What are you dealing with? 
 https://image.nostr.build/692c1198c495763de1434aabae87a58b6d742a10b750095dea950fa0d196e10d.png

each one is a different account.  you would have to block each one separately. 
 hello @hzrd149 

i tried muting the words ReplyGuy, GM and GM, ( with a comma ) 

but his replies still go through ...

 https://image.nostr.build/692c1198c495763de1434aabae87a58b6d742a10b750095dea950fa0d196e10d.png

nostr:nevent1qvzqqqqqqypzq9h35qgq6n8ll0xyyv8gurjzjrx9sjwp4hry6ejnlks8cqcmzp6tqqsyx7j7yjtd8lv4yfvqmmz53cvfdqn9h92ccfjdxemve3w7jww7qcsfag0su 
 I don't even understand what would motivate someone to do this in the first place