Oddbean new post about login | logout I don't agree. The difference is humans are capable of creating something new. Being inspired by previous works. Currently, AI isn't creating something new because it doesn't think, reason, doesn't have lived experience, etc. It is an algorithm which given some inputs (the prompt) is predicting what is the most likely combination of pixels to output based the training set. Its why you ask a model produce a cartoon crab underwater and it gives you something reminiscent of Mr. krabs from sponge Bob (since that was part of the training set). You ask a human to do this and you will get wildly different results based on the person and their lived experience. One day when ai is better I'll agree, but right now its hardly ai to begin with and more a fancy curve fitting algorithm. Not to mention this argument feels like it misses the point: as a creator it feels so shitty knowing you built something and shared it on some platform only for the platform to use it to make money of your work. It may also be illegal, though thats a different story altogether. I don't think any amount of "well acshually all art is stolen content" will change that.
> It is an algorithm which given some inputs (the prompt) is predicting what is the most likely combination of pixels to output based the training set this is what humans are doing. most humans generate output in the same way. they have more experience and context for sure, but that isn’t a hard thing for computers to get better at
I don't agree at all and I'm not sure our current understanding of the human brain is in line with what you're saying. Humans don't go about the world predicting the right word to say next. There is understanding of what was said to them to help formulate the response. Also the choice of words you use may change based on who you're talking to, the socio-economic context you're in, etc. There is certainly an element of memorization for learning language and even how we engage with the world but it is much more complex than simply predicting or curve fitting. If human brains worked this way, GPT models would be much better than they are and wouldn't need millions of training data points and thousands of learning hours to mimic what we do. There are obviously very large differences in how we think and how these algorithms work.
Thanks So I skimmed the website. Is the foundation’s goal just basically to digitize the board games? The way you described it in the earlier post is it was homeschool curriculum (for lack of better word) is how I understood it. For context , we homeschool our son. Currently use MiAcademy for “core subjects”. 1. It’s ok but still too “school” based in our opinion. 2. Looking for more real life / business skills education (which we have as his parents; but not necessarily looking to reinvent the wheel if I don’t have to) 3. Example, he’s into video editing so I’m essentially having to hobble together a “course” for him from YouTube vids and other paid courses we have access to that teach actual pro level video editing and business uses. —- So anyways…trying to understand your foundation as it relates to free and open source education…like what is the scope you hope to educate on…is it mainly the Bitcoin and finance stuff?
Thanks.
Humans produce things to express themselves, tho. Humans find other humans fascinating. The things they produce tells us about them, personally.
Nigel Farage accused of using MP role to boost profile by Lib Dem chief Wendy Chamberlain said constituency work is playing second fiddle for Reform UK MPs Lee Anderson and Nigel Farage, both of whom host shows on GB News #press https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/lib-dem-conference-nigel-farage-b2613132.html?utm_source=press.coop https://static.independent.co.uk/2024/09/13/16/52b0a09f2e35b0c4779e289d0c4f81efY29udGVudHNlYXJjaGFwaSwxNzI2MzI2MzAy-2.76927404.jpg?width=1200&auto=webp
What amount of the mass insanity is caused by a lack of new frontiers to conquer? https://image.nostr.build/749c247198ce2a5149e9572991f89cdc01fafbdc33aed2a69e5e3f58b0369611.jpg We have two frontiers right here, which will demand our best technology and human excellence, and can satisfy our need to conquer limitations for tens of thousands of years. Orbit - ringsteading Ocean - seasteading #frontiers #seasteading #space #tech #humanity
@PUBKEY Sent the ladies in today and they loved the decorations! https://m.primal.net/KrCr.jpg
SHALAMAR - A NIGHT TO REMEMBER https://video.nostr.build/e22177b5745eef158577a20839e95ff3a86bec3c22c364bfb59aef1fac4e3b1f.mp4
Dem Rep. Crockett: MAGA Is a Domestic Threat, Trump Is Stoking Them https://www.breitbart.com/clips/2024/09/15/dem-rep-crockett-maga-is-a-domestic-threat-trump-is-stoking-them/ #Zap to support, DM to suggest new feeds.
FYI Update: clumsy, messy husband me did not ruin her bread 🥖🤣 #grownostr #breadstr #foodstr https://image.nostr.build/180818399ec074a2e95912904fcb8cd4355a451457a8fc032cf96910426e4645.jpg https://image.nostr.build/c5936a1f8cc97546400033784eb9f1c5ba0d00eb33e50a97d0ebf74b1ae37577.jpg
JD Vance Keeps Doubling Down on Racist Lies About Springfield JD Vance loves a Sunday morning media blitz. In his latest round of television interviews, it appears he will not be swayed by the mounting evidence that the racist lies he amplified about Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, were eating pets—which former President Trump repeated on the... #press https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2024/09/jd-vance-keeps-doubling-down-on-racist-lies-about-springfield/?utm_source=press.coop
NOLAB 11 #nolab https://m.primal.net/KnUN.jpg
An idea I thought was cool was a lightweight PleromaFE compatible ap server that was designed with hosting multiple instances in mind, could work a bit like nginx, put options for each instance you want to host in it's own seperate config file. mainly want this because i am hosting multiple pleromas myself and its a pain in the ass to balance multiple source code files.
I have generated AI art that inspired wonder/emotion in me because it was so interesting to look at. It may be a derivative, but because I don't know the original inspirations, what I saw was new to me and thus I had a brand new subjective experience. I'd be interested to hear your take on this. Not using blanket statements, just thinking about on an individual level. What is the difference between me seeing AI-generated art and person-generated art if I don't know or care about the source, and the end result is the same? A novel, subjective experience that is different for me than other people due to my memory, experiences, and path through life. Is it still a net negative in that situation, or still just a "fancy curve fitting algorithm"? Or is it just... art at that point?
How you experience art is not the same question as whether or not the output of an AI model is art. It is interesting that ai generated images evokes those emotions in you. I find them souleless and same-y for the most part. But as you pointed out, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. But yes, to me what makes art is the human behind it or the experience of consuming it. Both can be art. But without both, you have products. Its why even in a distant or not so distant future where ai generated music is topping charts and many people are enjoying it, those same people are unlikely to go to a concert for such things. There will be some people that would of course and its interesting to imagine what an ai concert would look like but part of going to concerts nowadays is to support a band you love, feel the energy from them performing live, from the crowd, feeling the passion for the music they wrote ooze out of them. With ai generated music, you won't get that though consuming the songs may invoke similar feelings as it the ai generated image did for you.
