Oddbean new post about | logout
 The last month has been particularly bad (purple line) for new user retention.  I dont the the cause, but possible reasons are the Colorado attack, shift to outbox model or addition of web of trust.  Or it could be https://stats.nostr.band/



https://image.nostr.build/e0a5838861fd3e8b4a86c70846adade6079ba49d88e258b4954cd1c3236c94ad.jpg 
 Where do the meaningful conversations happen? Half a year ago, I often had the feeling, I could jump right into a conversation from my Damus home screen. Not anymore. 
 I hadn't been able to put my finger on what was different lately, but I think you just did. There used to be a lot more meaningful discussion amongst a wide array of people, like a big brainstorming session. Maybe that was a phase destined to pass, but it was fun.  
 There are fewer people here, now, who just "hang out". I was just complaining about how lonely it can be on here, now. People used to post stuff and wait for a reply, so there was this long interchange and other people could join in.

But then Primal brought the trending list and all the influencers showed up, and now it's just one person saying something into a megaphone to his groupies, and then walking off the stage, leaving the groupies standing around, discussing how much they admire him. Or people don't look at threads. They just doomscroll the OPs. But OPs aren't discussions, unless they're air-replies over a small relay (which is cool 🤩, the Japanese do that).

And because the big relays are really spammy/gross, and the clients discourage active relay management, everyone just looks at their follows, now, so it's getting harder to meet new people or to simply stumble across an interesting conversation.

Communities and forums would change that, but everyone just builds Twitter 2.0, so most of the conversationalists have moved to other venues. I'm one of the last holdouts, but my frens mostly come here, to keep me company, and not because they wouldn't rather chat in SimpleX group, Discord, GitHub, or whatnot. 
 I still don’t know who these people are, I only ever click the ‘hit’ tab on Nostur if I’m super bored. 

 
 Most people only look at the trending list, now, so it's become increasingly difficult for a normal user to start a conversation. 
 The hot tab is useful for information about the letter B.

Like Sesame Street but only ever the letter B and the number 21.

Are there any good sock influencers yet? That’s the mark of a successful platform, when the sock crew arrives, that’s when Nostr’s made it. 
 😂 
 IDK if randomly jumping into a thread I’m not a part of is cool, but being new to the platform I searched relay and this was one of the results and it’s so interesting! It prompted me to think about how it’s kinda strange/ironic how little connecting with new people, building relationships and being social has become on social media - at least in my own experience. 

But it also presents the opportunity to do something different if that experience applies to a lot of people and not just me. If social media is the main way people get, view or interact with  information, then any sort of expert in a certain field is helpful, but we also don’t want to create a “digital caste system” with social media that kinda reminds me of that 2016 Black Mirror episode “Nosedive”. 
 Anyways - thanks for sharing your thoughts unfiltered it was quite refreshing to read! 
 We got a wave of Brazilians trying nostr and they didn’t stick around. Maybe because it was hard to find Portuguese content or people to follow or a critical mass moved elsewhere. It’s worth investing.  
 Well, unfortunately, nostr is still full of glitches, and I assume that scares away quite some "average" users. 

My gf follows me (using damus on ios). Even after a week or so, I do not see her as a follower in my profile created with amethyst and also used via nostter. She also wrote me a dm. I opened it in amethyst, but when i wanted to reply something, a popup telling me that i have to pay something first appeared. I tried to change my profile picture in nostter - did not work. It worked with amethyst though. So basically, every feature I tried so far had glitches.

If I would not love the concept of nostr, I also would have been gone already.

I do not know what the next step is, but probably I have to dig a bit deeper into my profile's relay configuration. 
 definitely outbox