Oddbean new post about | logout
 Just something to think about is all. I don't want to pressure you into OSS, I do think closed source can be necessary in some cases. Specifically for nostr, I think many of us come here expecting to escape the requirement to blindly trust the product and its developers. I trust many of us here to be morally aligned but that can be quite naive. 

I personally prefer copy-left. Many prefer completely permissive licensing. For code that produces a product, I would personally (and usually do for my own code) choose the GPLv2+ or AGPLv3+. Both areGNU copy-left license. 

It requires anyone who uses your code build their own product to release your source (or their modified source) publicly. Damus is GPL I believe and its looks like Amethyst is MIT. AGPL has the requirement for server usage. That is if your code sits behind a production application but is not public facing, if changes were made, your code must be made available (with your name on it!) both modified AND your original source code. 

There are other more and less permissive licenses out there, but I appreciate the history of GNU and FSF defending developers using their licenses. 

It's probably going to take a while to choose a license you like, but it's meant to protect you AND your users/community. 

I may be on the extreme side, I won't lie, I like owning my code, and having my name displayed because I'm proud and have an ego, but I highly respect my user's rights, so once my code hits a user's hands, its theirs to do what they want with it. Free and always available as long as I'm working on it. That's why I use copy-left. 
 Amazing! Thank you for your patient and sincere sharing. This has benefited me a lot. Thank you so much. I will consider it carefully. 💜💜💜🫂🫡 
 Anytime! If you have any questions, feel fee to tag me or anyone working on the @GitCitadel project. 
 Thanks 🫂🫂🫂🫡 
 You lost me at "I do think closed source can be necessary" 
 Plenty will disagree. That's fine. I don't believe the world works in absolutes. I would be lying if I said closed source is never necessary. There will be circumstances I can't predict and valid reasons I haven't heard. I can't predict them, nor do I have much experience in the world of enterprise software development and product management.