@65b14323 
Consumer Reports current ratings of auto insurance companies, from least worst to most worst. (You must pay Consumer Reports money for more details.)

(92) USAA Group
(86) NJM Insurance Group
(83) Amica Mutual Group
(81) Erie Insurance Group
(80) PEMCO Mutual Insurance Company
(78) Acuity
(78) West Bend Mutual Insurance Company
(76) California Casualty Group
(75) Chubb INA Group
(69) The Cincinnati Insurance Companies
(68) Wawanesa General Insurance Company
(65) Auto-Owners Insurance Group
(64) Westfield Group
(64) Auto Club Enterprises Insurance Group
(63) State Farm Group
(63) Farm Bureau Property & Casualty Insurance Company
(62) American Family Insurance Group
(61) Horace Mann Insurance Group
(61) NYCM Insurance Group
(59) Plymouth Rock Companies
(58) COUNTRY Financial Property Casualty Group
(57) State Auto Insurance Companies
(54) Hartford Insurance Group
(53) Auto Club Group
(53) Travelers Group
(52) GEICO (Berkshire Hathaway Insurance Group)
(51) Hanover Insurance Group Property & Casualty Companies
(51) CSAA Insurance Group
(48) Mercury General Group
(46) MAPFRE North America Group
(46) Nationwide Group
(46) Farmers Insurance Group
(45) Progressive Insurance Group
(43) Allstate Insurance Group
(40) Kemper PC Companies
(40) Liberty Mutual Insurance Companies