Oddbean new post about | logout
 How's the reply spam situation been over the weekend? 
 It makes me happy in the pants 
 What kind of pants? 
 Loose ones that allow for maximum happiness. 
 Seems like its getting worse 😅 
 Steady as she goes 
 Personally, I'm not seeing a lot of spam. 
 Even in your replies? 
 Yes. I must have my relays configured just right? 
 Yeah, I’d think so. I don’t think I have it as bad as others. 

Also, I don’t hate the reply spam all that much. 

I dunno, maybe I have a high tolerance, or I’m just a touch lazy. 

Or both. 
 I see none. I added the emojis from impersonators to my Amethsyt filter too.  
 Why are they using emojis? That seems odd. Is it to take up more space? 
 they are replacing random words with emojis so you can't do duplicate content blocking 
 Makes sense. 
 Okay that makes sense. 
 How's your efforts been with mitigation? 
 haven't got around to it yet, I plan on hacking on noteguard again on the plane soon. lots of stuff I want to try wrt. ip blocking frequent posters beyond the rate limiter. 
 Spam is done now. The extra rate limiting helped but a permanent IP ban would be really nice too. It was all coming from a single EC2 instance (with occasional IP rotation). 
 yeah should be easy to stop in that case, until they start seriously rotating ips, but then maybe we could detect spam from ip blocks and block ranges instead. 
 I think the emojis were an attempt to get people to follow the impersonator accounts nd get them into WoT with lots of attention grabbing things.  
 Terrible unfortunately. If i turn off public relays, i stop seeing notes. if i turn them on, i get this.

https://i.nostr.build/uroYoKOQ7BK7icCu.png 
 That's not a good time for anyone. 
 Yeah I moved to mainly WOT relays . I’m seeing some weird things.

We keep moving! 
 Yeah, I tried the WOT relays, they are generally slow and my notes timeout a lot. 
 Are you losing your people you follow too? Like their notes disappear and they are in WoT  
 Yeah, I actually lost you. found that you had some note replies after i turned Damus back on. 
 Yeah, I think the WoT don't like me 😁 
 suspicious. 🧐  
 very 🧐 
 Buggy software 😩 I'm running a new version now that hopefully fixes the crashes. Then hopefully that fixes other issues that nostr:nprofile1qqsfev65tsmfgrv69mux65x4c7504wgrzrxgnrzrgj70cnyz9l68hjspz4mhxue69uhks6tnwshxummnw3ezumrpdejqzyrhwden5te0dehhxarj9emkjmn9qy2hwumn8ghj7etyv4hzumn0wd68ytnvv9hxgxenh8d is describing. 
 I added back in a couple public Rs.

I am seeing less spam but I did see a weird emoji thing going on.

Feeling it all out. It’s part of it.

The faulkers will make nostr stronger.
Faulk around lie around (coming from someone who isn’t going much about it, but will support those who can the best we can 👊 
 It's forced me to improve my relay management skills. 
 This is the way... Though new users won't do this. They'll just get turned off. 
 Not so bad  
 For now, no-one seems to care about me. This reply might change that... 
 🫂 
 I am seeing replies when using Damus but not when using Primal. 
 Good enough to swap back in nostr.band relay and remove the one WoT relay I was using 😀 
 Oh really? What has nostr.band done to minimize the spam? 
 I dunno. I just swapped it back in to try it. So far so good. 
 Zero for me💜


TLDR; report any obvious spam even if it takes an extra 30-60 sec.
 
I was quite adamant about 2-3 weeks ago to manually mute/report/block any npub that I could tell was spam
-took about a week
Also removing one relay that helped of course 
- can't remember which, obvious thing to check, do and it worked well

I have absolute zero spam



PS 
I often report/block/mute clear spam in others' note replies. This helped as well

#HelpYourFellowNostrich


 
 I used his own weapon against him. I flooded the spammer with my bot until he gave up on all the relays i was seeing him. haven't heard from him since. 
 https://media.tenor.com/lNMyjjSWLYcAAAAd/my-man-my-man-denzel.gif  
 he's probably just "regrouping" and figuring out how to evade my bot, so when he comes back, i'll need to figure out how to get back to him again, and so on... not really efficient. But it was fun! 
 Got rid of a bunch of relays and it’s working better 
  Fascinante si 🎊🎊😁 
 Ignore replies

* with many emojis
* with avatar picture being a reply guy
* with author using a non-verified nip05 identity 
 Aren't they using spamstr.lol now for their Nostr addresses? 😂 
 It seems like different public relays are being attacked at varying times. For example, there was a heavy attack on Damus, then it stopped for a while, only to return later. The same thing happened with oxtr, "wiz.biz", and a few other relays.

What I’ve been doing is disabling and then re-enabling downloads from the public relays under attack (while still writing to them so that people can read my messages).

It’s a bit chaotic. And IMO, most of the proposed solutions have had worse consequences than the spam itself. For instance, since some folks are "protecting  themselves" (i.e., hiding) exclusively behind WoT relays which I don’t have access to, I'm never sure if they’re even receiving my messages. Similarly, preventing folks without NIP-05 addresses from writing to a relay is even more damaging to new users than the WoT issue. Finally, it seems like the attackers are already PoW-capable, which means the PoW relays are just adding complexity for legitimate users.

As a user, what I’d like is a quick way to toggle between only viewing posts and replies from "connections of connections" to viewing posts from everyone on Nostr.

Apparently, Damus offers this feature. Do you know of any Android or web (but mobile-friendly) clients doing something similar? 
 Which wot relay do you not have access to? I'm finding all your notes on multiple of them 
 Hey Utxo, here's the issue. It's hard for me to know which WoT I can or can't write to. I've encountered a few "blocked: you are not in the WoT" errors, as well as frequent "rate limiting" messages, even though I haven’t sent many messages. I’m not sure which of these errors are legitimate and which ones are due to misconfiguration or glitches. I also tried adding a few WoT relays on a secondary client but couldn’t find my own post right after submitting it.

I'll be writing a few notes exclusively to WoT relays for testing. Since you likely have access to every WoT in existence, I’d appreciate it if you could give a thumbs up to the notes you can see. 
 Those errors are actually normal and you are probably only getting them once in a while. The wot relays, while refreshing the network, temporarily don't allow posting while it rebuilds the wot. Even I get those errors on my own relay.

Since I follow you, fairly certain you have access to every single one... 
 Thanks for the clarification, utxo. Now that you’re following me, it may boost my reach. After three hours, I still haven’t received answers on two out of three relays, although I did get replies from yours. I just offered to zap the first person who replies to my other two posts. Let’s see if I find any takers. 
 Nostr has been pretty quiet the past two weeks and it's still hard for new npubs to gain reach. 
 nostr:nevent1qqswq6v7exjd907zns3mlukkrez9w9e8lhured35y90896fsfqyh9fqpz3mhxw309akx7cmpd35x7um58g6rsd3e9upzps0f4va9dg4tdjjta06yafjt9ldyptrrz85gdw5xk3jjz6wt266rqvzqqqqqqypu8gry 
 Thanks for replying Derek. For reference I haven't received a single reply or reaction on wss://nostrelites.org/ for almost 3 hours. And I have even bumped it by self-replying to my post:

nostr:nevent1qqsxmglrv3e8adtrh6uzd9q98fr76akmjlxy65up76z2d87wmy99mqcpxdmhxw309adnycfsxyargc3sxqaxzepsxsarxc3sxqaxzvp5xqaxvenx8fnx2wpk8gmnzdmxt5argwpk8yhsyg8wnkteuls5rz5lw3et47pde9sg9gx5y5dh0093wznwemynlt0lvspsgqqqqqqsl6mudd

I'm now offering sats publicly and there's still one relay where folks haven't found my post (it has been 3 hours and counting). 
 Lol, you were faster than me and already replied to the other 2 :). So this means that my posts are readable, WoT relays are just quiet. Thanks nostr:nprofile1qqsw9n8heusyq0el9f99tveg7r0rhcu9tznatuekxt764m78ymqu36cpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuat50phjummwv5hsz9thwden5te0veex2mnn9e6hg7r09ehkuef0qyfhwumn8ghj7am0wsh82arcduhx7mn99ue0hx63, I'm sending a few zapz your way. 
 I'm not seeing those reply spam anymore after rearranging my relays. I believe it was an issue with certain relay providers. I think it's important to notify them about this problem so they can address it. 
 Seems better today. Yesterday a little less.