Oddbean new post about login | logout Treemap of the top 30 note topics we’ve classified so far from nostr.wine over ~12 hours of kind 1s. I suspect we are over labeling technology a bit but then again everything is technology. https://image.nostr.build/f2a5195707d69c06558e1de2f3fcd80acbaafc179a9e6f788a0b1bab2c2cddd0.png
I’d be interested to see if technology and bitcoin overlap some, but this seems to disprove the “nobody talks about anything but bitcoin” trope so many complain about. I think it’s more likely that the biggest accounts talk about bitcoin, but not most accounts, if that makes sense.
There is lots of overlap for sure. Check it out yourself: https://search.nostr.wine/app/discover#/view/dc3500b0-cc04-11ed-b988-2561bfd60652
Less than I thought - 89/2290 have technology + bitcoin.
I think it goes to show a lot of content is already here. The effort must be put into curating your own feed. This chat made me feel bullish on #Nostr . Thanks for posting this experiment. ❤️
I’m going to add back programming as a topic as well because I think technology is a bit generic for posts like @e6ddbf8c64cc8ef864df0d8ec0c371e8410909d67ac5c3f071f8ad0207e80262
Given today's date I'd say this is under counting https://image.nostr.build/6925661f199dbc8da0c05afbe40cc7796d2ec47c5af797ea4d00e67587d8265e.jpg
gm ☕️
Photography? 0?
Other is ten times the smallest section?!
Other is a place holder because I’m only showing the top 30. So the 7% in other are a mix of topics shared by <0.77% of all notes. At 50 topics (in this photo), you’ll see other drops down to 2%. At 100 topics, it’s barely visible and unlabeled. https://image.nostr.build/3b11cf9b865e6a45f29c949900b5c142ff46437fa433e0b59a76e8d12d0a7a6e.png
"Good morning coffechain" is what? Food? Greeting? Diet?.... 😁
Check it out for yourself! You can query the results easily here: https://search.nostr.wine/app/discover#/view/dc3500b0-cc04-11ed-b988-2561bfd60652
It only shows "loading elastic" for me. But don't worry. We just like to randomly give devs a hard time. The stats and chart is actually very cool.
Ahhh perhaps a browser/javascript issue? Wasn’t trying to be sassy just wanted you to see/play with the data. Short answer: it depends on how it’s worded! https://image.nostr.build/a3aa7011a1daf8b728baf149278b4c238d68c1e5f083803a0531473a1a232099.png
This cannot be true. Memes are at least 69%. https://m.primal.net/HLCG.png
69.69% to be exact
I gotchu. https://image.nostr.build/6d7c677ebe37d02cb74b49e1ecb3b6b2cfb68176ed11f6a6a2483050e3436738.jpg
No way
Synchronicity is beautiful.
Damn nice son
Only 12% greetings. We need more GMs now!
Deploying more GM, steady lads
Buen día para ti
this is interesting. though i keen to know how do you decide the categories?
It’s a mix of a classification model + LLM for when none of our topics are a high probability fit.
interesting! and this data, will it be open sourced or paid kn demand?
For now anyone can access the results here as a guest: https://search.nostr.wine/app/discover#/view/dc3500b0-cc04-11ed-b988-2561bfd60652 Long term our plan is to allow filter.nostr.wine subscribers to create custom feeds using our topics/language/sentiment labels through our relay. We can also offer the classifier as an API (that will not be free) and classification results through an API (perhaps a freemium model). All of that is TBD. This is my weekend proof of concept.
Here's one for the health category. I'm about to take a big ole shit 💩 nostr:nevent1qqszkeav8c3vyvv9mv7ww5derfsjmuz6uyhpavpkwf2k8t0agx2eeagpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumt0wd68ytnsw43qygpass40an279ylj3dnz0yehqj3lhr8p2w4fr4us4vgldf6j639y95psgqqqqqqsxax3mw
We sure do love to greet one another here 🫂💜🤙🏻 nostr:nevent1qqszkeav8c3vyvv9mv7ww5derfsjmuz6uyhpavpkwf2k8t0agx2eeagpzemhxue69uhk2er9dchxummnw3ezumrpdejz7q3q8kzz4lkdtc5n729kvfunxuz287uvu9f64ywhjz43ra482t2y5sksxpqqqqqqzjuyren
good morning
Good afternoon.
good evening
Art 2.35% These are rookie numbers We’ve gotta pump these numbers up
Unfortunately probably victim of the same problem as memes, though they could certainly be pumped nonetheless. nostr:note1zzv7zrcc4vwnhu464pt8g42n5dlp0q237pruxhfl5t3jxry0djmq46m27k
Uhm gotta pump the woodworking talk, I can't see it in any category in here 😁
Coming back on the monotheme of Nostr. Lookie look, nostr is evolving from being a niche protocol to people expanding their interests 🤙 nostr:nevent1qqszkeav8c3vyvv9mv7ww5derfsjmuz6uyhpavpkwf2k8t0agx2eeagppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0qgsrmpp2lmx4u2fl9zmxy7fnwp9rlwxwz5a2j8tep2c376n494z2gtgrqsqqqqqpu65jgr
surface greetings and bovine tech worship has replaced meaningful discussion god worship... are you really all this shallow or is it the fear of losing your #socialcapital that turns you into voiceless conformists ? signs of things to come... https://image.nostr.build/1b231659202ce7b0cde4c434cce057ab181a4b6e5152539e7af262a7adcc2bbe.jpg
Can I subscribe to fitness?
Wouldn't it be cool if we could subscribe to these?! #asknostr nostr:nevent1qqszkeav8c3vyvv9mv7ww5derfsjmuz6uyhpavpkwf2k8t0agx2eeagpzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezuamfdejsygpass40an279ylj3dnz0yehqj3lhr8p2w4fr4us4vgldf6j639y95psgqqqqqqsmf6vh5
2.07% on #memes is quite disappointing https://image.nostr.build/e231023d4676d5ed61b36191380d1c4f7b3461cfc2311c036dd3e2a34040324e.jpg
Unfortunately, they will always be underrepresented because we aren’t currently looking at posts with ONLY images at all (mostly memes) We simply pull the content type from the url and set it aside for later classification. Eventually…
Are hashtags enough to get classified into the correct category? Great job, btw 🤙💜
Shitposters and #meme frens, we've got work to do! 2.07% is simply unacceptable. nostr:nevent1qqszkeav8c3vyvv9mv7ww5derfsjmuz6uyhpavpkwf2k8t0agx2eeagpp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqzyq7cg2h7e40zj0egke38jvmsfglm3ns4825367g2ky0k5afdgjjz6qcyqqqqqqg6wcsd8 https://image.nostr.build/e231023d4676d5ed61b36191380d1c4f7b3461cfc2311c036dd3e2a34040324e.jpg
How did you generate this?
First pass of our topic classifier + elasticsearch + Kibana. nostr:note19py7qhtwh9sft82hqgl4lqr9k2kwwn8gwkv2qnqvwjhp9t3jyhps0jv8qx
As an Information Scientist, I love this
You can explore the data yourself here: https://search.nostr.wine/app/discover#/view/dc3500b0-cc04-11ed-b988-2561bfd60652
nostr:note19dn6c03zcgcctkeuuagmjxnp9hc94cfwr6crvuj4vwkl6sv4nn6slhygke Treemap de los 30 temas más importantes que hemos clasificado hasta ahora en nostr.wine
A categoria XXX deveria ser criada também. https://image.nostr.build/5b60fad5d837772a7ac0b67bb55fed2f52cb8ec54fd57ac67afb9d1b0ef93603.jpg
This is great to see! nostr:note19dn6c03zcgcctkeuuagmjxnp9hc94cfwr6crvuj4vwkl6sv4nn6slhygke
This is a really cool experiment! Do the labels you're creating get published to the wine relay or a set of relays as well?
Nothing yet, still a very early experiment. Lots of refining to go before its production ready but we will try to offer them in as many ways as possible!
Ahh, ok so it's not that new labeling nip32 then yet? I was reading up on that. It's a little bit confusing now to use labels the 'right' way but I'm pretty excited that some smart people are giving this a lot of thought..
Nope, nothing nostr native for now (besides the source of the notes of course). You can explore the labels here: https://search.nostr.wine/app/discover#/view/dc3500b0-cc04-11ed-b988-2561bfd60652
music is really low! let's make this place a little bit more vibey =)
I am happy with my contribution to #bitcoin , #nostr and #meme 😊 nostr:nevent1qqszkeav8c3vyvv9mv7ww5derfsjmuz6uyhpavpkwf2k8t0agx2eeagpp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqzyq7cg2h7e40zj0egke38jvmsfglm3ns4825367g2ky0k5afdgjjz6qcyqqqqqqg6wcsd8
Interesting. My timeline goes the other way😐😆
Good morning, from ring of fire nostr:note19dn6c03zcgcctkeuuagmjxnp9hc94cfwr6crvuj4vwkl6sv4nn6slhygke
lol... greetings 12+%
Actually surprised Bitcoin is only the third biggest topic. But positivity surprised at the same time... a wider range of topics being discussed = Nostr appealing to a wider range of people.
