Charcoal in pine tar? But that's not going to be a nice finish...
I think that would be a good binder, not sure if the pine smell would go away. I would not want everything to have a pine taste. I don't really care about the finish, as long as its black and heats up the air.
If you're concerned about taste/smell, all of my suggestions are terrible. 😅
Lol. I love pine smell, just don't think apples would pair with it. This would need tested first