I loath communism, but I can make the same argument about democracy and or capitalism.
Then, of course, people would claim that what we had was bastardized capitalism, not the real capitalism under which we would thrive.
Both are BS with different names, and both use the same failed arguments to explain why they didn't work the last 20 attempts. Then both claim "If we could just try it again, it'll certainly work!".
The reality is that both are faces to the same coin. A plot designed to extract wealth from you and give it to your master.