Of course, but claiming nostr is doomed due to X is shortsighted. It's thinking adversarially without thinking optimistically. Buttcoiner thinking is pointing at a problem and immediately claiming it's unsolvable.
Totally agree, even if you are skeptical of it, how has being involved in Bitcoin not taught you the lesson to continually challenge your beliefs and try new things? That's one of the biggest things that protocol did to impact me as a person. I question everything, but I also am constantly questioning my own beliefs.