Oddbean new post about | logout
 All GDP is based on people giving each other handjobs for cash. 
 I don't think you can really do an apples-to-apples comparison of economies when one of them (Russia, in this case) has essentially decoupled from the international financial system. 
 You say international financial system, I say handjobs for cash.  Same thing. 
 while GDP is indeed fake, having lived in USSR, Ukraine and America there is a real difference as well.

perhaps a real measure of wealth and power of a nation is how many cars it has on its roads.

Russia - 57 million cars
Germany - 48 million cars
USA - 290 million
China - 415 million cars 
 or let's pretend EU and NATO is the same thing for car counting purposes

Ukraine = 9 mil cars
EU = 250 mil cars
US = 290 mil cars
Total = 549 mil cars

versus

Russia = 57 mil cars
China = 415 mil cars
Total = 472 mil cars

and yes in fact our cars are NOT made in China

there are very few cars sold in US that are made in China such as Polestar 2 and those are getting hit with not quite sanctions, but they do lose federal tax incentives that made in America electric cars get ... 
 I'm not sure that's a great gauge since most people agree that mass transit is a good thing and countries with good mass transit (Like Germany and Japan) have less need for cars. It's still way better than GDP though, I think! 
 most people also agree that vaccines are safe and effective and eating bugs prevents weather.

here, i have some writings ( my own ) for you on the subject:

https://dissidentsound.discoursehosting.net/c/urbanism/urbanism-explained/88 
 I'm glad I typed "most people" instead of "everybody"!

You don't like trains? I thought it was pretty neat to not have to park,  unpark and fight traffic when I visited Tokyo. Just swipe your suica card at the turnstile and ride! 
 so like i already wrote about a hundred pages on that subject:

https://dissidentsound.discoursehosting.net/c/urbanism/73

and in fact i also encourage people to read it. 
 my writings are a result of years of debating professional city planners on Twitter before getting banned ... 
 although you all should still read the hundreds of pages of my writings explaining all this i will give you a hint here so that you don't think i'm being rude and dismissive.

the hint is this: all the traffic and parking issues are ENGINEERED by city planners. this isn't a "theory" this is from actually talking to them. they don't deny this. they now admit creating traffic and destroying parking is the GOAL of their profession.

what do you think lockdowns were about ?

read my writings on my site to learn more ... 
 Thank you for the summary. I appreciate it! 
 Urbanism is the single greatest victory of the WEF against the dissident right.

most on the right have swallowed it hook line and sinker.

i specifically address the infiltration of the right by Urbanist agents like Wrath of Gnon here:

https://dissidentsound.discoursehosting.net/t/wrath-of-gnon/579 
 Cars are also a retarded metric. 
 come up with a better one and let us know. 
 Just a quibble that while entire Chinese cars are not sold in the U.S. most (all?) cars will have some raft of subcomponents sourced from China 
 Isn't Volvo a Chinese-owned company now? 
 yes it is.  i drive a Volvo currently. 
 that is true.  for electric car to get full federal tax incentive not only the car has to be made in US ( or partner countries ) but the same for the battery and minerals used to manufacture the battery.  this is all designed to punish Chinese manufacturers and support American ones.

the point is our leaders aren't as dumb as you think.  they thought of this stuff. 
 As people have mentioned, GDP is an extremely bad metric for pretty much anything expect politicians lying.

What is it drastically poor for is a war-time comparison. German is a) massively dependent on oil from Russia. b) Germany has knee-capped itself by going all in on "green" energy. They had no ability to scale energy usage for wartime, and in fact are already facing major issues just running factories right now. 
 Putting economics aside, surely Germans realize at this point that their country doesn't have a great track record when it comes to wars against Russia. Will they agree to turn all of those BMW factories into tank factories? Will they happily sign up for a draft? Their Supreme Commander would be Joe Biden, who isn't exactly an inspirational leader. Are German politicians even ALLOWED to be inspirational?