Oddbean new post about | logout

Notes by Chris Geidner | export

 BREAKING: After trial, federal judge declares Texas's anti-drag law, SB12, unconstitutional and issues a permanent injunction barring — through AG Paxton — all state officials from enforcing it. More to come at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/132/953/155/709/475/original/55fd03df3130f0eb.png 
 Breaking: #SCOTUS rejects Alabama's attempt to ignore its congressional map ruling.

My Law Dork report on today's big news: https://www.lawdork.com/p/scotus-rejects-alabama-congressional-map-stay 
 I am an independent journalist covering our legal world. Your support is essential. To keep up with my work, subscribe to Law Dork today — there is a free option! To help make this work sustainable, consider a paid subscription. https://www.lawdork.com/ 
 nostr:npub1p0wyn67cd9cm80vj6ds5crpss5sg76jplv32v6mn23szgexu3yxqq822r5 

Dear C
if you had to gues... 
 @04a10faa today is a very good sign they cannot. 
 On Monday, the special master appointed by that lower court released possible maps with two such “opportunity” districts. 

A hearing on the report is set for the lower court next week, with quick action expected thereafter to move the new map forward. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302.295.0_1.pdf 
 I am an independent journalist covering our legal world. Your support is essential. To keep up with my work, subscribe to Law Dork today — there is a free option! To help make this work sustainable, consider a paid subscription. https://www.lawdork.com/ 
 Alabama passed a map this summer with just one majority-Black district after the Supreme Court affirmed a lower-court ruling that two “opportunity districts” were required. Alabama was asking #SCOTUS to let it use the one-district map. The court resoundingly said no this morning. 
 On Monday, the special master appointed by that lower court released possible maps with two such “opportunity” districts. 

A hearing on the report is set for the lower court next week, with quick action expected thereafter to move the new map forward. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302.295.0_1.pdf 
 BREAKING: The U.S. Supreme Court rejects Alabama’s attempts to use its new congressional maps that a lower court ruled illegal or stop that lower court from redrawing the state’s congressional maps to conform with the Voting Rights Act. There were no noted dissents.

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/131/815/690/136/022/original/58c4e130f62b7080.jpeg

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/131/815/834/815/749/original/d444469aab31eb01.jpeg 
 Alabama passed a map this summer with just one majority-Black district after the Supreme Court affirmed a lower-court ruling that two “opportunity districts” were required. Alabama was asking #SCOTUS to let it use the one-district map. The court resoundingly said no this morning. 
 On Monday, the Fifth Circuit took a series of unusual actions — each in one-sentence orders — in the Texas book-ban law case, “religious-liberty training” sanctions, and Biden admin social-media influence case. Read about the orders & effects at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/fifth-circuit-adf-training-book-ban-social-media 
 Thanks for sharing my posts on here today. If you don’t know me, I’m an independent legal journalist. Law Dork operates on individual subscriptions, so I need your support. If you’ve been following my work here, please consider subscribing there: https://www.lawdork.com/ 
 And, I understand that not everyone can pay — and that some just aren’t ready to pay for Law Dork (yet). That’s fine! Sign up anyway, there’s a free option. I don’t want to wall off this work because I think it’s important — or else I wouldn’t do it. https://www.lawdork.com/subscribe 
 "The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit was in rare form on Monday, even for the most conservative appeals court in the nation." 

New tonight, at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/fifth-circuit-adf-training-book-ban-social-media 
 BREAKING: The Fifth Circuit issued an administrative stay halting the "religious-liberty training" Southwest Airlines sanctions the day before the ADF-led training was set to take place. The admin stay request was not opposed by the plaintiff. Background: https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/128/863/279/777/114/original/99573a70dfefbb03.png 
 As a result of this order the airlines' lawyers do NOT need to attend the training tomorrow. For now. The Fifth Circuit still needs to rule on the request for a stay pending the airlines' appeal of the sanctions order. Tonight's order: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca5.211751/gov.uscourts.ca5.211751.115.1.pdf 
 The court gave no reasoning for its order, which is remarkable given that the law has never been allowed to go into effect, so the order — although posed as merely “administrative” — is a ruling, at least temporarily, changing the status of state law. 
 BREAKING: A three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit (Elrod, Haynes, Douglas) allows Texas’s book-ban law to go into effect, issuing an administrative stay of the district court ruling enjoining enforcement of the law. Background: https://www.lawdork.com/p/trump-appointed-judge-rips-texas

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/127/991/181/669/873/original/90f221c00eb89292.jpeg 
 The court gave no reasoning for its order, which is remarkable given that the law has never been allowed to go into effect, so the order — although posed as merely “administrative” — is a ruling, at least temporarily, changing the status of state law. 
 ATTENTION: North Dakota remains the only state with no paid Law Dork subscribers. If anyone in North Dakota is reading this, please consider a paid subscription to Law Dork today! (Also: Anyone, anywhere else, too.) https://www.lawdork.com/subscribe

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/127/568/510/908/161/original/7f9d4e31ffaa857e.png 
 Breaking: SCOTUS will not stop the scheduled execution of Anything Sanchez today. There were no noted dissents; Justice Gorsuch did not participate. Background: https://www.lawdork.com/p/oklahoma-executions-drummond-sanchez

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/103/606/366/688/196/original/c627681a71f15ce1.jpeg 
 NEWS: Full appeals court likely to vote on whether to rehear Alabama trans care case after three-judge panel ruled in Alabama's favor last month. 

Background on the original decision at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/appeals-court-ruling-alabama-trans-care-ban 
 Oklahoma is scheduled to execute Anthony Sanchez on Thursday. More on that and the status of Oklahoma’s 25-person execution spree at Law Dork this morning: https://www.lawdork.com/p/oklahoma-executions-drummond-sanchez 
 As I noted earlier, Southwest has said in court filings that the religious-liberty training is set for Sept. 26. So, there is still *some* time for action. But, the sanctions are now back in effect. 

More at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions 
 ALSO: A reminder that I am an independent legal journalist checking the federal courts’ dockets at 12:01a CT. Your support is key to keeping this essential reporting going. Subscribe today and consider a paid subscription if you can afford one: https://www.lawdork.com/ 
 UPDATE: The sanctions ordered against Southwest Airlines — including the order that three lawyers attend "religious-liberty training" — are now back in effect, as no court extended the 30-day administrative stay previously issued to allow appeals. https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions 
 As I noted earlier, Southwest has said in court filings that the religious-liberty training is set for Sept. 26. So, there is still *some* time for action. But, the sanctions are now back in effect. 

More at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions 
 In other news out of Texas, that "religious-liberty training" ordered as sanctions in a case against Southwest Airlines has been on hold. The stay expires in 8.5 hours, though, and the 5th Circuit has sat on Southwest's stay request. Read it at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions 
 If the order goes back into effect, Southwest has said that the religious-liberty training — ordered by Judge Brantley Starr to be conducted by the anti-abortion, anti-LGBTQ ideologues at Alliance Defending Freedom — is set for Sept. 26. So, there is still *some* time for action after today. https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions 
 Those “religious-liberty training” sanctions that a Texas judge ordered aren’t gone. In fact, they are set to go back into effect on Sunday. Thus far, the 5th Circuit hasn’t even responded to Southwest’s request about the “unprecedented and unlawful” order. https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/071/354/269/229/135/original/cb45ee52359323e9.jpeg 
 Those “religious-liberty training” sanction that a Texas judge ordered aren’t gone. In fact, they are set to go back into effect on Sunday. Thus far, the 5th Circuit hasn’t even responded to Southwest Airlines request about the “unprecedented and unlawful” order. https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/071/332/948/642/778/original/b5341d6fc94c36a4.jpeg 
 Those “religious-liberty sanctions” that a Texas judge ordered aren’t gone. In fact, they are set to go back into effect on Sunday. Thus far, the 5th Circuit hasn’t even responded to Southwest Airlines request about the “unprecedented and unlawful” order. https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/071/244/756/851/389/original/2d83fd9fc2fa19d1.jpeg 
 NEWS: The 30-day hold on the “religious-liberty training” sanctions order against Southwest Airlines expires Saturday night. So far, the 5th Circuit has sat on a request to extend the stay. As of now, the ADF training is set for Sept. 26. https://www.lawdork.com/p/religious-liberty-training-sanctions 
 NEWS: DOJ opposes Trump’s request for recusal of Judge Chutkan in USA v. Trump (DC), arguing that Trump “falls far short” of meeting the standard for recusal. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.258148/gov.uscourts.dcd.258148.54.0.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/066/995/812/895/556/original/0a2b1ca93a4adf47.jpeg 
 Here's a note writeup of this news at Law Dork: https://substack.com/@chrisgeidner/note/c-40087604 
 BREAKING: Justice Alito, acting as circuit justice, issues an administrative stay, halting the social-media case injunction until 11:59p ET Sept. 22. Response from the challengers is due 4p ET Sept. 20.

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/064/992/883/933/518/original/839d1a98d06794f8.jpeg 
 The SCOTUS docket will be 23A243.

I am an independent legal journalist, covering this fast-paced legal world at Law Dork. Your support is essential. Subscribe today: https://www.lawdork.com/ 
 Here's a note writeup of this news at Law Dork: https://substack.com/@chrisgeidner/note/c-40087604 
 I covered the Fifth Circuit's ruling on this, which the Biden admin is now seeking to stay, in my Sunday roundup at Law Dork here: https://www.lawdork.com/i/136880475/the-other-news

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/064/454/889/831/038/original/969f766997ddc19d.png 
 The SCOTUS docket will be 23A243.

I am an independent legal journalist, covering this fast-paced legal world at Law Dork. Your support is essential. Subscribe today: https://www.lawdork.com/ 
 BREAKING: The Biden administration goes to SCOTUS in case seeking to limit the admin's interaction with social media companies, asking the justices to put the lower courts' injunction on hold while the Supreme Court decides whether to hear the case. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23977660-23a243

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/064/424/540/984/796/original/38ab823ce81ef1c0.png 
 I covered the Fifth Circuit's ruling on this, which the Biden admin is now seeking to stay, in my Sunday roundup at Law Dork here: https://www.lawdork.com/i/136880475/the-other-news

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/064/454/889/831/038/original/969f766997ddc19d.png 
 #SCOTUS note: There are two Alabama redistricting filings — one in the three-judge case (23A231) and one from the one-judge case (23A241). The different underlying cases lead to different procedural requests at SCOTUS, but the court is almost certain to consider them together. Background at Law Dork here: https://www.lawdork.com/p/alabama-voting-rights-scotus-trans-care 
 NEWS: The 11th Circuit orders an extremely expedited. briefing in Mark Meadows's appeal of his removal action attempt, with briefing over the next 15 days. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.84175/gov.uscourts.ca11.84175.17.0_1.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/059/912/120/968/240/original/bb9b9a6db67bf8d5.png 
 BREAKING: A three-judge panel of the 11th Circuit (Wilson, Jordan, Rosenbaum; all Dem appointees) will hold oral arguments Friday morning over Mark Meadows request for a stay pending appeal in his removal action appeal. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca11.84175/gov.uscourts.ca11.84175.23.0_2.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/060/048/015/651/377/original/882757d71b7e1bea.png 
 Alabama’s AG is trying to restrict people’s rights on multiple fronts currently, defending the state’s refusal to follow the Supreme Court’s voting rights ruling and asking to short-circuit the appeals process to enforce its anti-trans law. https://www.lawdork.com/p/alabama-voting-rights-scotus-trans-care 
 Republican Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall is busy, fighting against Black people’s voting rights and trans people’s right to medical care. New, at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/alabama-voting-rights-scotus-trans-care 
 nostr:npub1p0wyn67cd9cm80vj6ds5crpss5sg76jplv32v6mn23szgexu3yxqq822r5 

Is not "the duty to sit" ... 
 @3e804985 I mean, that possibility is specifically why I wrote, “Under current rules,” in the piece.  But, structural reforms weren’t the point of the piece. And every piece isn’t going to get into structural changes that are possible — particularly at a time when they aren’t going to happen. 
 In case you missed it: On Friday evening, both the Biden administration and the maker of mifepristone went to #SCOTUS in the case over abortion medication access. Read about it, and get the filings, at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/doj-and-mifepristone-drugmaker-go 
 Here’s my report on DOJ and Danco Laboratories *both* seeking cert at #SCOTUS on Friday in the mifepristone case (with both petitions posted, of course), and more. New, at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/doj-and-mifepristone-drugmaker-go 
 BREAKING: The Biden administration goes to #SCOTUS in the mifepristone case, as expected. Based on the Fifth Circuit's ruling, DOJ is asking SCOTUS to hear its case for the 2016 and 2021 actions easing access, including ending the in-person dispensing requirement. 

Here's the full DOJ cert petition: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23945337-usfda-et-al-v-alliance-for-hippocratic-medicine-et-al-petition

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/031/865/734/418/452/original/a62f5a45590d8b14.jpeg 
 BREAKING: The Fifth Circuit, in an unsigned opinion, upholds aspects of the injunction against the Biden administration relating to social media companies. It ultimately narrows the injunction to one provision, which it alters to the following: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca5.214640/gov.uscourts.ca5.214640.238.1.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/031/831/351/477/192/original/f4258c2f7b3978c5.jpeg 
 Alito’s statement can be found at the end of a set of SCOTUS orders here: https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/090823zor_21o2.pdf 
 This is crap; more to come; subscribe to Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/ 
 The Tenn. AG, after fighting alongside the Blount County prosecutor all last week, essentially said earlier this week, "Yeah, we should just wait on that other case, b/c that decides everything. We won't fight an injunction in the meantime." Stipulation: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tned.111061/gov.uscourts.tned.111061.35.0.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/025/144/845/654/448/original/c559868170a030ae.png 
 Law Dork has been covering this matter at length. See, most recently: https://www.lawdork.com/p/blount-county-tennessee-tro-anti-drag-law 
 NEWS: Fed'l judge in Tenn. grants preliminary injunction against enforcement of the anti-drag law in the Blount Pride case, upon agreement of the parties. Injunction will be in place at least until the 6th Circuit rules on the Friends of Georges appeal. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tned.111061/gov.uscourts.tned.111061.43.0.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/025/134/196/466/684/original/2d2b548297023628.png 
 The Tenn. AG, after fighting alongside the Blount County prosecutor all last week, essentially said earlier this week, "Yeah, we should just wait on that other case, b/c that decides everything. We won't fight an injunction in the meantime." Stipulation: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.tned.111061/gov.uscourts.tned.111061.35.0.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/025/144/845/654/448/original/c559868170a030ae.png 
 nostr:npub1p0wyn67cd9cm80vj6ds5crpss5sg76jplv32v6mn23szgexu3yxqq822r5 moment of silence for that ... 
 @2470e277 That too — though I assume mapmakers would be fine with it? 
 UPDATE: Special Master in Alabama is moving ahead with remedial map plans, per this latest order—seeking any party’s proposed map by noon Mon CT. Non-parties have until noon Wed CT to submit proposals, w/ comments on all proposals due by midnight* Wed CT. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302.282.0.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/021/890/253/020/841/original/e2488368c6b5c2d7.png 
 * = I know, I know. 
 Monique Worrell sues DeSantis, as she should. The second elected prosecutor DeSantis has attempted to oust, Worrell’s suspension order was even more vague than the one issued against Andrew Warren.

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/021/338/907/506/615/original/1eafaad231e3ba7d.jpeg 
 If you're just catching up from the weekend, I've published two reports at Law Dork since Friday: 

- one on Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment and Trump's disqualification from being president under it: https://www.lawdork.com/p/trump-is-almost-certainly-disqualified

- one on the Sunday night ruling in Georgia halting enforcement of that state's new ban on hormone therapy for trans minors: https://www.lawdork.com/p/georgia-trans-minors-hormone-ban-injunction

Check them out, and, if you've not yet subscribed to Law Dork, go for it — there's a free option! 
 Breaking: Judge blocks Georgia's ban on hormone therapy for transgender minors 

New, at Law Dork: https://www.lawdork.com/p/georgia-trans-minors-hormone-ban-injunction 
Event not found
 @a81369bf True shitshow! I cheat by just saying “ET," on that front. 
Event not found
 UPDATE: Special Master in Alabama is moving ahead with remedial map plans, per this latest order—seeking any party’s proposed map by noon Mon CT. Non-parties have until noon Wed CT to submit proposals, w/ comments on all proposals due by midnight* Wed CT. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302/gov.uscourts.alnd.179302.282.0.pdf

https://cdn.masto.host/journahost/media_attachments/files/111/021/890/253/020/841/original/e2488368c6b5c2d7.png