Oddbean new post about | logout
 A Bitcoin question…

I spoke to a shit coiner today and he said he was hesitant to buy BTC as he was concerned the CIA “made” it. I couldn’t really come back with a good reply. I mentioned Satoshi but he,  “how do you know?”

Any suggestions for next time. (Apart from HFSP😂) 🙏🏻

*keen to see the difference in replies from here or the Twitter. 🙌🏻 
 Ask him the hypothetical: "what if the CIA did create it? What changes? Could they put a backdoor in the code that hasn't been discovered in 14 years? Would it still be better money than the USD?" 
 Cheers Baz… I think we all agree that the OS software cannot be mucked with… but maybe the coins down the track move…? I know, long term this wouldn’t matter though. 🙏🏻 
 I see. 
Well the coins could still move no matter if it was the CIA or someone else... 
 It could if someone had the original source code. But it would take a genius to something like that. Besides: they would have to be malicious & uncaring to do that.  
 I think the best approach is to just clarify what he's saying. So you're going to miss out on the greatest wealth distribution in modern history because you think the CIA invented it? This is what you'll tell your grandkids when they ask you why you didn't buy bitcoin at 58k?

Regardless of who Satoshi Nakimoto was he's not around & no single person or organisation controls Bitcoin.

Bitcoin core, the most widely used validation software is the most scrutinised peice of software in existence. Regardless of who is mining the blocks, every block is validated by that FOSS software.

I believe it was the NSA that invented SHA & Bitcoin uses SHA256. I don't recall the CIA being involved but I guarantee they use it.

It's like saying I'm not going to use Tor or torrents because I don't know who invented it. 
 Well explained. 🙏🏻
Though I think the gripe with if it WAS them, is will they move the coins. 
 That's why it's best to clarify 🤣

It's an irrational fear & it's always best to walk out their logic. 

If the CIA sell all their Bitcoin, then we have the biggest fire sale ever & it'll take 3-6 months for price to recover.

But why would they sell? The CIA like power & off the books funding sources for operations. Can you imagine how useful a Bitcoin stack would be for them? 
 Yep! 

But “they” wouldn’t even have to sell “all” their BTC… just move one Sat to make things interesting. 🙏🏻🙂 
 A handful of 50 Bitcoin UTxOs moved for the first time in 14 years last week.

They weren't Satoshi's coins but they were from that era. The market didn't seem to mind too much. 
 It doesn't matter who started it. Many more people have contributed now to the code. Also thousands of people run nodes and or mining equipment. The CIA has no more power to change the code than anyone else. 
 I think it isn’t the code that’s the issue but the million odd coins. 🙏🏻 
 DARPA too : 

It was a long-term solution to world peace. 

Many countries involved as well. 

Show them what has happened in Africa since adoption :

Unless he’s a racist. In that case he doesn’t deserve #btc 

https://youtu.be/d5AvBsxRMYk?si=or5Fb_E7Ho6equUr 
 #pleb is a first year student at #WestPoint or #USMA in the #USA so if that person or anyone else is against #btc or #nostr 

It’s easiest to explain we built everything on the ashes of past generations 

Many hate me for admitting I’m a retired #Fed but to them I say this: more good was done worldwide in what I chose to do. 

1. #PACT act was a direct result of things I chose to do. 🫡

2. No #war should exist. Excellent in that area & saved far more lives than I thought possible. Truly. 🫡

3. #Information #Warfare has raged on always. Some work boots on ground. Some online. There are bridges to gap. 

Dedicated myself to #Aaron #Swartz memory & will continue even if no one else understands. Never needed recognition before. Won’t change anything. 

As a #poet it’s helped me come to terms with a lot. 

—
Young woman worked hard
Winning mens created games
Little honor found 

- She remembered she’s a Queen 

Big boys club will rage 
When they must bow to, Her Grace
Historic truths rise 

- Remember  

#poem
——
Here : 

Many will never understand the price others have paid for them to be able to live blissful in willful ignorance. 

- Ingratiated ingrates 

#poetry # 
 Thinking it’s a bot. 🤷🏻‍♂️😂 
 I’ll use every resource possible if it gets people to think. #AI is coming in hot. 🥵 

What some give freely others exploit. Always

Narrative warfare is constant. It will be  interesting to see it play out on a scale modern humanity hasn’t yet experienced. 

The LOLS 😂 make it worth it.  
 Everyone plays the fool sometimes. It’s a mug game.