Oddbean new post about | logout
 nostr:npub1xkwaswarxtyfywx0exf0ve9kheuzj4c6py745r6fvfm0nfz6ctlsne7jwu 
Fair points. (I imagine some of this is about word limits). It's clearly a prototheory (not yet a theory). Whether it can ever be a testable theory is debated. 

Given how high the stakes are here (the ethics of organoids, AI and coma patients (also eating salad 😉​)), how wrong some journalists are getting this, and the fact that the path to this becoming a testable theory is very unclear, I endorse the term pseudoscience in this case. 

That said, understanding consciousness is also one of the most challenging problems humanity has ever faced and I support the prototheory's development.

(BTW: I understand that the team will be posting responses to pushback (including this point) in a few days).