I appreciate the input but a problem is I've read books before that other people thought were solid only to find them to be very lacking at best.
And maybe they would think the same about some books I like.

I bet if we both saw the same Christian/atheist debate I would say the atheist won and you would say the Christian won.
And I have a feeling that with this book you would say he was very convincing and I would say he wasn't.

If he brought new winning arguments to the forefront then I would expect them to spread throughout the Christian community.
So, I think I'll wait for some of those arguments to appear first.