Only if the payment went back to me... would have to be over 1000 sats.. and I am assuming there would be a grace period before I could unmute them again so they get their moneys worth... 

I think there would need to be a setting for us to allow such things also, especially certain content.. most people I mute is because when I open my stream I see porn or someones nuts on my screen, so they get instablocked.. I wouldn't want them to be able to pay to come back even...