Oddbean new post about | logout
 You wake up, it’s 2026. 

Trump has implemented a strategic Bitcoin reserve and worked with Treasury Secretary Jamie Dimon to issue a Bitcoin backed government currency.

Bitcoin is trading above $500,000 measured in today’s currency. 

Half of the country is interacting with it through a government digital wallet where they have Bitcoin credits and cannot hold keys or access the base network. The other half either hate digital currency or hate Trump so much that they are boycotting.

What would your reaction be? 
 Proceed as usual. 
 Yes 
 Stay humble and stack sats  
 Wouldn’t surprise me lol but I’m more pessimistic 
 What’s a more pessimistic hypothetical? 
 That they ban businesses from accepting bitcoin through a non government approved wallet. Not saying this will happen, usually what happens is somewhere in the middle of my pessimism and the overly optimistic statist bitcoiner. 
 That’s definitely a possibility too 
 I would use Monero. Trying to increase merchant adoption. 
 Does monero scale to the merchant level though? 
 What is the problem?

Remote nodes can be used over tor. And because BTC is a perfectly decentralized store of value some centralization within Monero as medium of exchange should be acceptable.

It's only problematic when maxi ideology ignores trade-offs (perfect auditability vs perfect privacy, perfect decentralization vs scalability).

Once you accept that Monero and Bitcoin are complimentary a lot of things become much more easy.

The future is bright. 
 Sure, but if some centralization as a medium of exchange is acceptable, why not use ECash or a Bitcoin side chain? 

Then you wouldn’t have to worry about the scaling issues of a blockchain (monero is less data efficient per transaction) and you wouldn’t have to worry about currency arbitrage every time you make a trade 
 Ecash is great for small amounts. There are trade offs in all things. And in Monero even if miners and nodes would be centralized they could not censor transactions as they don't know what to censor.

Bitcoin to store value.
Monero to spend money and store privately (accepting higher risk similar to USD inflation in off shore bank accounts).
Ecash to spend change. 
 that would be a funny plot twist: the Democrats would end up learning how to self-custody Bitcoin in order to protest Trumps new government digital bitcoin wallets. 
 My intention was a bit more bearish, I was assuming the other half would keep using dollar banking or paper money 
 you gave some fun scenarios to think about:

for the breakaway liberal half:  Fear of being unable to pay for an abortion or birth control pills due to banks reporting transactions to the states would have caused many left-leaning women to research money and either invent a new anonymous protocol or adopt the best pseudonymous messaging and payment protocol they could find.  "No KYC" will have made it into all of GenZ vocabulary by mid 2025. A whole generation of communist leaning youngsters would be furiously protecting every last no-KYC Satoshi private property.

for the Trump-obsessed right wing half: when they are told that they have to park all their bitcoin at the Fed and accept CBDC-USD... some will do that, many will also try to self custody or custody at banks in the states/jurisdictions where they trust the local government and law enforcement better.  

The federal government then attempts to pay employees and contractors using the CBDCs while requiring the states to accept the CBDCs as payment for goods and services from the federal employees. If the federal government attempts to debase the CBDC-USD, the states will start noticing the price difference between their own bitcoin reserves and the CBDC-USDs that the federal government is pushing them to accept.  Perhaps the states will start requiring the federal government to pass audits in order for the states to accept the federal CBDC in their state.

Ultimately once the budgets are balanced, the CBDC-USD is either bankrupted or done away with as a useless peg to Bitcoin. The brand that once was "US Dollar" is now a thing of the past in 2030. 
 so ultimately, not bearish, possibly bullish as more cohorts of people are incentivized to protect what they see as their own rights/property 
 Not interested in that scenario 
 Let’s say that’s what happens - what do you do? 
 I'd ignore it