Do nostr users even want nostr to grow?

Do folks view nostr as the freedom tech for all, or a way to be in a bubble away from those you dislike?

It seems that there’s some pessimistic self sabotage that will surely make those who join leave after one day.

Ego can kill.


It feels like a big old echo chamber and click to me at the moment. Despite trying to engage others, I'm frequently talking only to myslef.


I'm content with my circle of friends. Don't care about everyone else.


Clique*


I think nostr should find a way to attract more crypto oriented individuals!

Like make it a home for them.


i’m sorry you feel that way kris 🫂 i hope theres a change one day


Crypto is gay. Bitcoin only.


i try to talk to people all the time, i think we are not their cup of tea or whatever


I’d appreciate $400 🙌I’ve never held BTc to my name before 🥹


Stop asking for handouts you fuck.


Who’s “we”?


The best you can do is ask for my wallet nut


I think it’s just a really small user base Kris.. getting to know people etc just takes time too, and there are many IRL connections on here that maybe changes the comms between people. anyone is free to build community tho


Yes.


me? kris?


fuck you Kris, I can see this post and don't agree. fuck off or engage with me motherfucker. ps, hope you're well & much love to you my FAM x


I was thinking maybe a solution to the onboarding problem could be selling $9 onboarding in small corner stores where you can buy phone cards, photocopies and notary public services?


chill b


sorry


I meet new people on nostr all the time. Some are new users. Not all of them. Not sure the new users leave because they don’t like bitcoin. Seems to me like a lot of newcomers leave because they don’t engage much, just gm and gn. I see some get frustrated because they dont get much responses to their gms. I’m not sure that’s the way to go about it 🤷🏾♂


this is true as well


there’s a lot of layers to the issue.


Seems to me like the gms and gns are a double edged sword.
What the newcomer sees:
-A stream of GMs + a flow of sats

What they don’t see:
-Consistent interactions between npubs for weeks (months) … (+ the GMs)

It seems that some make the mistake of thinking that GMs = sats and interactions. When the interactions actually need to come first. Creates a lot of frustration for some newcomers


That's a vlaid point AK. It is a small user base currently. I can also appreciate real like connections. I'm fairly new to many of the topics that are relevant in the current active community. I ceratialy recognize that community building is a open opportunity to all. And in do try to foster community here when I can from my seat.


Hi Sarah. In hope you had a good weekend.


Yes. My bad. Poor spelling on my part. Thanks for the correction.


I did actually, and I hope yours was a good one as well. If not, I hope it ends better. Have a great week, and I will always be here to chat. xo


Yes.

nostr OGs are weird😅

feature not a bug🤙🏽


I'm well. Ty. I'd be happy to have a conversation with you. Best to you as well.


nice bro :) x


I don’t fit in the bubble here except for holding bitcoin but this is the only place I can say bitcoin without getting banned 😂


No worries friend! It's a weird word. A little bit like queue.


It was good. Thank you. The weather was poor one day. But today was beautiful, allowing me to enjoy the outside. I hope you have a productive and good week as well. I appreciate the note and offer to chat - likewise from me.


That's a great idea


Awesome, I look forward to chatting. I had a nice today, yesterday wooo, it seemed gray, but today, it was warm, sunny, and beautiful, plus i got to photograph some cool things today for work so i am happy. xo


where do u get banned for saying it?


ps i just followed you


I think what you're referring to is just the general disdain for influencer culture. Nostr has been a refreshing break from the constant flow of that, but inevitably it will become more predominant at some point. Almost everyone tries to make regular new users feel welcome, but they have to take the wheel in order to achieve the experience they want to have.


Not too sure. I think if we move to a perspective of relay-as-community where both users and relay owners can communicate content that they want more or less of, there might not be such a need for influencers


I’ve been using for 2 years and feel that way 😅💜


Thanks! Same. Perhaps I can ask for a virtual reading sometime. My partner does them for me occasionally. But I’d love one from outside my immediate circle.


The influencer is in the relay? 😂


Yeah, there is not enough of a user base to get a reasonable network of people with interests other than nostr and Bitcoin.


It feels that way to some extent. I’m encouraged by some of the content in a technology sense. And I strongly believe in the privacy and fundamentals of the design constructs. I do hope the space succeeds in adoption at scale.


Do nostr users even want nostr to grow?

Do folks view nostr as the freedom tech for all, or a way to be in a bubble away from those you dislike?

It seems that there’s some pessimistic self sabotage that will surely make those who join leave after one day.

Ego can kill.


More seriously though, I do think community oriented social will be a huge draw once some solid examples get rolling.


I feel at home in nostr in the same way that I felt at home in a stone circle in the nineties. how much info do you need?


Yes. Organically.


Yeah. I don’t care if those I tell about #nostr join, because if they’re not smart enough to get it, well…. I do care about the devs tho, and their ability to pursue their talents and dreams, so I guess scale is important for more than just my personal opinion and insular comfort.


i want it to grow so it keeps interesting but i don't want normmie facebook stuff so in that way i do not care for mass adoption


I don't know why communities didn't work out. A Reddit style nostr client would be great for discovery and plugging into like minded people. The UX is a bit glitchy on Amethyst for communities.


If the community cares to have one, perchance? 😂


yours,?


😂🤣 we both know some will... that story is as old as time


Completely untapped there right now, trying to maintain a town square - but town squares don't have 1000s of participants with nothing in common.

Now, if we have hundreds relays, some more popular than others, some centered around a theme or location.

Users have personal curation feeds for "i dont care for their notes at this frequency, but they're welcome to say what they want" to "i don't want you swimming in my pond" and sending a report to the relay operators (WOT for example)

Relay operators should be able to get reports and other info from their users in whatever resolution is useful on who are good faith players on their relay.

Having those tunable knobs is how we solve the spam and toxicity issue.


yes


me? read? like tarot? yes. you are the first on nostr to ask.


Bright new horizons 💜 if I wasn't cooking right now I'd rattle off some thoughts I've had in the past (sparked by points the jaf has made) 😅


Yes. Tarot. A pleasure and happy to be the first to ask.


Imagine how many sleepless nights before they were able to ship their own respective clients. No amount of sat can compensate genuine hard work


yes, lets set a time!!!!!!!!!!!!


from one post here I learned enough to keep me busy for a week if I didn’t have to finish a plan with dozens of photos, drawings and a material list


That does sound appealing. I’ve struggled to keep up with the active development of implementations (clients and other) at times here. I just have limited time. I’m trying to move more into active use of Amethyst. It’s feature rich. Damus has been my daily driver. I need to explore more and expose myself to other opportunities to engage with others.


Would love that. I’ll do my best to keep in touch over the week, perhaps to do so on a weekend day. It’s a little challenging during the weekdays, to keep up here. Ty for the conversation. Have a good night! 🫂


yes, next weekend perhaps!


If someone leaves, that’s on them. I really don’t care.


Such as?


Definitely want growth... Freedom tech circle jerk is boring.

I just think a grown up version of this protocol will look very different than grown up platform.

We’ll need to make a new playbook.


Trying to attract and hook users as fast as possible is venture capital exit strategy thinking. We are bringing back the open web, outside of the big tech silos. It entails creating compelling software of every type, not just twitter clones, over nostr, and people will organically find the value and that's how it grows.


Please bookmark it then! Want to read it 😁
Reflecting on who i interact with a lot, its less the influencer type, more tight nit than other social media. Nice to see what the popular ones are doing but i care more in my extended circle of friends.

Definitely not the only way people use nostr, but there's at least a few of us here and i think exclusive relays - not paid, not computational (WOT), but just a relay where I have a lot of overlap in interactions, and I'll get invited because my content is appreciated and trusted to not be toxic.
 https://media1.tenor.com/m/olnkZI1dcQQAAAAC/arrested-development-david-cross.gif


Me: use Nostr, you can't be banned or censored

Twitter user: Nostr sounds interesting but there are all sorts of legal issues if people send kiddy porn over your relay and the feds raid you so legally it's your kiddy porn.

Me: you don't have to run your own relay if you're worried about that

Twitter user: erm

Me: also Nostr only sends around text and URLs, any images or video are stored on other servers just like with the rest of the Web

Twitter user: sounds risky though. I think I'd better stay with the censorship


It's more like a garden that needs a bit of tending each day. We should all quit taking things so seriously online. Cyberspace isn't real.


Some collective ego check is certainly fair criticism for everyone to carry going forwards


100%. i also need to check my own ego as well


We all do. All civilizations have realized this since ancient times, love reading Marcus Aurelius as a reminder. But it’s easy to hear/read and very hard to actually do it.


most people don't get the use case and the other half don't understand or don't give a shit about bitcoin


Sides of a coin 🪙


Sometimes I detect deliberate self sabotage on nostr, feels like it's not done maliciously but there seems to be a worry that nostr might grow out of being 'this could've been a bitcoin telegram group. And to remedy that it regurgitates bitcointwitter to ward off the unfamiliar.

Total tinfoil hat theory tho;)
(Just an imo)


nostr is free and open to anyone who wants to use it. What is the issue?


not a tinfoil hat theory, that’s the truth


more than Bitcoin Twitter.

🌏🧑🏾🚀🔫👩🚀🌌

https://www.nostrapps.com


more than Bitcoin Twitter 💜🤙

nostr:naddr1qq2k5ctdv95kxctw944x2unt943ks6trddjkuq3qm64hnkh6rs47fd9x6wk2zdtmdj4qkazt734d22d94ery9zzhne5qxpqqqp65wxmr5n9